Users Online Now: 3154  |  September 29, 2024
LBzrule's Blog
Tiered Play calling and other thoughts 
Posted on November 14, 2008 at 11:43 AM.
After my initial response I had to sit back and reflect. While I still want new Dline stunts as a part of the on the field play calling, my enthusiasm for this game has taken a dive. I'm not sure what to believe about it to be honest. I think Ian is telling the truth that tiered play calling is a lot of work. However, I'm a bit puzzled. Why hasn't their "rewrite from the ground up" made this installation a lot easier for them? Why hasn't the rewrite made fluid multiple player tackling, combo and double team blocking easier for them? I just realized that some of the things I asked for, such as team specific packages are possible, BUT, not doable due to playbook memory constraints.
Comments
# 1 rudyjuly2 @ Nov 14
Re-writing things from the ground up the same way they did them is what caused this problem. From a software side, the initial build is the most costly. You can change things much easier while building it but when you have a final code, changing a major component like a two-tiered system creates havok. It's especially true given their time frames.

It's one drawback of having an annual release cycle. You never really see a sports game redo a graphics engine or any major component during a console's life span. Most consoles are considered to have a 5 year life span. After that, all the resources are poured into the new technology. If we can get the console makers to stretch out the console life to 8 to 10 years, it might give an incentive to a developer to re-invest true development time on an existing title. Otherwise they all build the base engine for Day One and just tweak it until it's dead. We don't really get any significant improvements after this. Just a slow, evolutionary improvement. Nothing revolutionary.
 
# 2 LBzrule @ Nov 14
That's exactly why my enthusiasm took a nose dive because EA built a base similar to what they already had. Their play system will be the same throughout this generation of consoles and the play system has impact on how the game is played. At the end of the day I look at it this way. EA had a building on PS2/Xbox and that building had a core. On 360 and PS3 they have a new building, BUT, the big question is, is the frame/core the same from PS2/Xbox? Right now, the way the game plays it sure APPEARS that way.
 
# 3 LBzrule @ May 2
You know after playing the game, even though I want the tiered play calling eventually, I think I'll survive and thrive to a degree.
 
LBzrule
40
LBzrule's Blog Categories
LBzrule's Screenshots (0)

LBzrule does not have any albums to display.
More LBzrule's Friends
Recent Visitors
The last 10 visitor(s) to this Arena were:

LBzrule's Arena has had 65,986 visits