might be madden bucause of the nfl teams and if they model the game after the ncaa then that makes it that much better. I rather play All Pro than both to tell the truth b/c i havent really seen anything that makes me want either or...

NCAA 12. Looks to have a lot better replay value, deeper dynasty, better gameplay, and better graphics. The only thing I think Madden has that NCAA can't beat, as of right now, is co-op online.

Now I'm really hopefully that they get that in NCAA. lol

Im going with NCAA 12 because i love 11 and 12 is just going so much better with new presentation, graphics, gameplay, dynasty, etc.

I'll give a slight edge to college football but that could change quickly. The quality of the two games look very similar this year. I love recruiting and building a dynasty is NCAA but the one thing Madden has to offer that NCAA doesn't is a playoff system. I know this isn't the all games fault but if NCAA football 12 did have a playoff i would definitly have it over Madden. I just hate the BCS system

If I had to pick just 1... It would have to be Madden. NFL is my fav sport easily. I do watch college but not as crazily as I do the NFL.

To early to ask this question. I need to hear more details as to the improvement of each title. The key for me is online franchise in Madden. I'll be getting NCAA because I trust that they won't screw up but yet add to an already solid online dynasty offering. I'll only get Madden if I read good things about online franchise improvements. I rarely watch college football, I'm a die-hard NFL fan but even with that Madden (without improvements for online franchise) gets boring to me after playing it for a couple weeks. I'm still playing in an NCAA 11 online dynasty league to this day.

NCAA 12. Easy for me since I prefer college football but the dynasty mode is far more addictive than Madden's franchise mode.

Madden 12 - the improvements to the game. Liking the screen shots. It's the NFL man, that's why.

If I could only pick one it would be Madden because I am bigger fan of the NFL than college.

Going with NCAA 12 this year.

Madden 12 for me. Not that big on college FB.

It's too early to decide, we still havent heard enough about Dynasty mode or franchise mode to decide. But i'll go with Madden, like dannyheck said, "it's the NFL man."

NCAA12 for me as well. Dynasty mode is the key selling point for me. Although I do not follow NCAA football hardly at all in real life and love the NFL - vidoegame wise, NCAA is a more rewarding game fro the longterm for me.

Neither right now. NCAA 12 is a no right now because of the defensive zone coverage. No player should ever be able to strafe and back pedal as fast as a receiver or half back is running. Did you guys watch the zone coverage video for NCAA 12. That says it all.

For Madden 12, I need to see fluid animations that do not look and feel robotic. I want to feel like I cannot put either of these games down, but right now, I feel like I may never pick either of them up.

I will stick to Backbreaker and All Pro Football 2k8 for now until I see a major improvement in gameplay for both of NCAA 12 and Madden 12.

It's pretty hard to choose between both of them. NCAA Football 12 looks good so far & gotten little bit more information than Madden NFL 12. Until I get some more information out of both of them, it'll be neither.