The OFFICIAL NFL Week 1 Fantasy League Lineup Advice Thread

[Suburban Rhythm]

I am starting:

Brees
Lynch
S Holmes
Boldin
Crumpler
Kaeding

I can start one more WR/RB out of:

Chris Chambers, Ronnie Brown, Bernard Berrian, Sidney Rice, Rudi Johnson, Kenny Watson & Bryant Johnson.

Leaning towards Chambers. Any other thoughts?

[Icy]

I would put Chambers too, he should do well this year if he wants to prove that he is a top receiver besides some spectacular catches from time to time. R.Brown will get carries but the starter will be Ricky Williams.

[Izulde]

This is the first year in a long time I didn't get a chance to do fantasy football. I miss it already.

[MikeVic]

I think Chambers is the only guy there where there's more of a chance of him doing alright versus the other guys. No one really know how the Dolphins or Bengals will use their RBs yet, and I'd give the other WRs a week or two to see how they do with their teams.

[Izulde]

Yay! I was able to jump in on an ESPN fantasy league that has their draft in an hour.

[PurdueBrad]

Ronnie, I would start Galloway. He has a history of destroying the Saints.

[PurdueBrad]

I'm having a struggle of my own. Favre or Hasselbeck? Jets play the weak Dolphins that have no Taylor or Thomas this year. Their secondary only allowed about 185 yards passing a game last year BUT 28 TDs. The Seahawks play the Bills, who allowed about 240 yards passing a game but only 18 tds. Thoughts?

[PurdueBrad]

Originally Posted by Ronnie Dobbs2

Is his groin going to hold him back at all? I was going with him at first, but now leaning towards White.

I'm starting him as one of my three and he has said for the last three days that he's ready to go. My belief is that he goes.

[henry296]

Interesting one. Palmer vs. Kitna

I have a feeling Kitna will have a big game and the Ravens defense can be tough.

[PurdueBrad]

Originally Posted by Ronnie Dobbs2

Favre vs. Hasselback is a toss up to me. Seattle's missing some weapons as well.

I'm tempted to go Favre because no Branch for Seattle and Engram is questionable and because I get the Jets game on the television so I can yell advice to Brett on every play.

[Suburban Rhythm]

Favre vs. Hasselbeck

I'd probably go with Favre. Hasselbeck is probably the higher ranked player, but who is he throwing to-- Burleson and ????? and add in Buffalo is a much better defense.

Favre has a good matchup against Miami and has his top 2 WRs.

Kitna vs. Palmer

I'd probably still stick with Palmer. If anything, Cincy should have an easier time throwing than running, IMO. Reed is still Reed, but those CBs are a year older, and weren't great last season. Palmer might throw some picks that hurt, but should have a ton of opportunities to rack up yardage.

[molson]

Originally Posted by henry296

Interesting one. Palmer vs. Kitna

I have a feeling Kitna will have a big game and the Ravens defense can be tough.

I like Kitna too, he and Warner might have their best matchups of the season this week, I'd put both of them in over guys like Palmer, Hasselbech.

I think Warner's going to through 3+ TDs today, and he's available in a lot of leagues.

[PurdueBrad]

Thanks for the advice guys. Jon Kitna just got dropped in our league, should I drop Favre and pick him up for the rest of the way? As I said before, my other QB is Hasselbeck.

Scoring is 1 pt. per 20 yds passing, 6 pts for a td, -2 for a int/fumble, 1 pt. per 10 yds rushing

[Suburban Rhythm]

Originally Posted by PurdueBrad

Thanks for the advice guys. Jon Kitna just got dropped in our league, should I drop Favre and pick him up for the rest of the way? As I said before, my other QB is Hasselbeck.

Scoring is 1 pt. per 20 yds passing, 6 pts for a td, -2 for a int/fumble, 1 pt. per 10 yds rushing

I don't know if that is any sort of upgrade, from Favre to Kitna.

[henry296]

Should've made the switch... Palmer = 0 points; Kitna = 15 points.

Don't think it will matter in the result.

[TLK]

Any thoughts on this trade...

Point system rewards for TD's, yardage and milestones.

Carson Palmer, Matt Forte and Hines Ward for Peyton Manning and Thomas Jones

My starters before:
QB- Palmer
RB- Marion Barber
RB- Kevin Smith or Forte (Started Smith in Week 1)
WR- Reggie Wayne
WR- Dwayne Bowe
WR- Hines Ward
TE- Zach Miller
K- Adam Venatieri
DEF- Pittsburgh

My starters after:
QB- Peyton Manning
RB- Marion Barber
RB- Kevin Smith or Thomas Jones
WR- Reggie Wayne
WR- Dwayne Bowe
WR- Santana Moss or Sidney Rice
TE- Zach Miller
K- Adam Venatieri
DEF- Pittsburgh

Any thoughts?

[PackerFanatic]

I think both Forte and Ward are going to be great this year. Manning was so-so on Sunday, but Palmer was miserable. Jones should be decent as well, but I think you gave up way too much for them.

[TLK]

Originally Posted by PackerFanatic

I think both Forte and Ward are going to be great this year. Manning was so-so on Sunday, but Palmer was miserable. Jones should be decent as well, but I think you gave up way too much for them.

It was actually a trade I was going to offer.... I didn't after reading your post. Anyone care to do my work and suggest a better trade. Manning is the guy I want out of the deal. He likes Forte and wanted help at WR. Here are the rosters....


Conquering Fools
QB Carson Palmer, CIN
QB Marc Bulger, STL
RB Marion Barber, DAL
RB Kevin Smith(r), DET
RB Matt Forte(r), CHI
RB Ricky Williams, MIA
RB Brandon Jackson, GB
WR Reggie Wayne, IND
WR Dwayne Bowe, KC
WR Hines Ward, PIT
WR Santana Moss, WAS
WR Sidney Rice, MIN
WR Jerry Porter, JAC
WR Darrell Jackson, DEN
TE Zach Miller, OAK
PK Adam Vinatieri, IND
Def Steelers, Team Defense, PIT

Master of Puppets
QB Peyton Manning, IND
QB Matt Hasselbeck, SEA
QB Jeff Garcia, TB
RB Clinton Portis, WAS
RB Thomas Jones, NYJ
RB Chester Taylor, MIN
RB Ahmad Bradshaw, NYG
RB Deuce McAllister, NO
WR Calvin Johnson, DET
WR Laveranues Coles, NYJ
WR Isaac Bruce, SF
WR Devin Hester, CHI
WR Devin Thomas(r), WAS
TE Vernon Davis, SF
TE Heath Miller, PIT
PK Mike Nugent, NYJ
Def Giants, Team Defense, NYG

[Suburban Rhythm]

What positions do you start weekly?

Is he interested in Bowe at all? While Huard will be an upgrade from Croyle, I can't believe that Bowe can continue to put up numbers while being the only weapon on that team.

[TLK]

Originally Posted by Suburban Rhythm

What positions do you start weekly?

Is he interested in Bowe at all? While Huard will be an upgrade from Croyle, I can't believe that Bowe can continue to put up numbers while being the only weapon on that team.

QB - 1/1
RB - 1/2
WR - 1/4
TE - 1/2
PK
DEF

Would it be a good trade if you substituted Bowe for Ward? He said he was looking at Bowe, but preferred Ward.

[Mizzou B-ball fan]

FYI for those that might be in a big league that uses a lot of players. Huard and Thigpen will be splitting time at QB for the Chiefs........

ESPN - Huard to start Sunday, but Thigpen may play soon - NFL

[Suburban Rhythm]

Originally Posted by TLK

QB - 1/1
RB - 1/2
WR - 1/4
TE - 1/2
PK
DEF

Would it be a good trade if you substituted Bowe for Ward? He said he was looking at Bowe, but preferred Ward.

I am looking at it as-

T Jones = Forte - Chicago might run more as the Chicago offense stinks, but Jones will catch passes.

So you are left with Palmer + WR = Manning
I think Ward is too much to give up there.

Of course, all of this is assuming you believe Manning turns it around.

[TLK]

Originally Posted by Suburban Rhythm

Of course, all of this is assuming you believe Manning turns it around.

Did you see the garbage Palmer put up Sunday? Am I giving up on him too soon?

[Suburban Rhythm]

Originally Posted by TLK

Did you see the garbage Palmer put up Sunday? Am I giving up on him too soon?

Yes. And Yes. At least my opinion.

He still has TJ, Ocho and eventually Chris Henry to throw to. I just don't like to jump ship after one week.

[Suburban Rhythm]

My week 2 lineup question is, not surprisingly, the same as my week 1 question.

I will start:

Brees
Lynch
S Holmes
Boldin
Fasano (FA pickup, dropped Crumpler)
Kaeding
ARI Def

I have a flex spot open for one of the following motley crew-

Chris Chambers, Bernard Berrian, Sid Rice, Bryant Johnson, Ronnie Brown, Rudi Johnson and Kenny Watson.

I used Chambers last week, and he got me 10+ points...but all on one play, the 44 yard TD.

Chambers will face, in theory, a good Denver secondary.
Watson has an awful matchup vs. TEN
Johnson...he plays for the 49ers
Brown and Johnson are not starters (yet)
Berrian and Rice...I am intrigued. But they still have Tavaris Jackson throwing to them.

Mushin Muhammed is available as a FA.

[Anthony]

people like you who jump ship after week one are the reason why other people wins championships. i would love to have you in my league. i wouldn't use any lubricant either. you wouldn't be sitting for a week.

[wade moore]

Rather than start another thread, looking for advice..

I need to fill RB1, RB2, and RB-WR (always a RB of course) and I have to pick from these 5:

Will McGahee
Kevin Smith
Jerious Norwood
Darren Sproles
Ahman Green

I can pretty much eliminate Ahman Green immediately, it's the other 4 that are causing me issue.

What 3 would you play?