[DaddyTorgo]

Lynching the cultist is not a great move since the cultist counts as a villager. Lynching the fake seer is also not great since the fake seer counts as a villager.

However you as the cultist have the ability to cause a lot of havoc (and since the wolves know who you are they won't night kill you) and misdirection.

If we lynch you and you're the seer I think we assume 100% that you were the fake seer and operate on that assumption.

Either of those two ways, yes we are down 1 villager, but since we are likely to lynch a villager on D1 anyways, getting rid of someone with the ability to confuse and disorient us (whether on purpose or not) is not that large a negative.

And if you are a wolf, we've netted a wolf.

I suppose there's an argument for keeping the fake seer alive if it's "the fake seer scans everyone opposite of what they really are" -- but of course nobody knows if this is the case, and i think it's far more likely as someone broke down earlier, that the fake seer scans everyone as villager.