Quote:
Originally Posted by Vince
I think the issue is that the guys have clearly delineated themselves into the haves and the have nots, and the guys on top are clearly a cut above their competition. The girls, on the other hand, are much closer to each other in terms of talent. I tend to believe that the top guys ARE more talented than the top girls (Cook and Archuleta, specifically), but that in general, the girls have more talent overall. We'll see much better when they're all thrown together.
|
I agree with you about the guys. There are good ones, and there are really bad ones. As for the girls, there are good ones, and mediocre ones. I think some of the better guys fell off a little this week (a lot of pitch problems and missed notes).
Most dissapointing for all of them: there isn't anyone who stands out as a whole package (looks/singing/performance/personality). I don't remember seeing that in the three seasons I've watched (3,4,5), I remember someone really standing out before the top 12.