View Single Post
Old 03-05-2008, 08:32 PM   #412
adubroff
High School JV
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
I think it's hard to pick the losers from tongiht. It was pretty evenly spread. I didn't love Carly and I normally do, I hope she's safe....

syesha - She closed the night like rivera in his prime. nothing really innovative here but the talent is clear and evident. I thought she nailed it.
Kristy - I liked this performance a lot. She owned the song and she has a lot of talent.
Remyel - she sung the heck outta this one and it was a tough one.
Brooke - gave it her own stamp. she countrified as well. I think this would have been even cooler a capella
Kady - good song choice for her. Doing Mercury is tough but it's sort of an operatic pop song and she showed the big voice we haven't heard yet.
Asia - solid performance of tricky song given original artist. She's talented but not Whitney.
Carly - a little flat in the choruses. I like Carly but I also expect more from her.
Amanda - better song choice. last week she was atrocious this week she's just bad.
adubroff is offline   Reply With Quote