Quote:
Originally Posted by Ksyrup
OK, then I don't get it. Why shouldn't it be that way? What makes AI different from any other attempt to find a recording artist?
If you want to argue against the recording industry or what America wants/ like, then fine. But don't act like AI should take it upon themselves to force-feed America with a "star" that America most likely won't embrace. Having Melinda Doolittle win last year might have made YOU feel better, but I don't think the suits who funnel cash into the show and the subsequent recorded product would have felt so good, because they understand the deal.
|
This probably does a better job of what I'm trying to say than anything I've said.
You (MJ4H) feel I'm not taking technical ability into account enough - I think you're giving it too much weight.. *shurg*..
On David's performance I think we just disagree completely on the emotion conveyed and that's such a personal preference I don't think we can say either of us is right or wrong.