[GoldenEagle]

I did NOT see what the fuss over Mandisa was about. I thought she did very well, but I have heard better vocals this season. I think its been said time and time again that American Idol is just not about the vocals. Paris and Mandisa can sing, but they do not have the total package. I thought Lisa was mediocre tonight. Kellie does not have the best vocals, but she can get by and she is very likeable.

I take a look at Paris and think that she belongs on the Cosby Show instead of American Idol. I think Simon was right on in the fact that Kinnik and Melissa will be going home tonight. Also, you can tell that Ayla is doing something that she is not up on stage. On all the clips, she is in athletic wear. But up on stage she is all dressed up and does not look comfortable. I laughed when that metro sexual guy stood next to her.