Next page baby!

I saw 14 people in the forum and got all excited until I realized it was 11 bots.

Abe, it is a compliment. I don't know what was spotted, but I just think it is a pretty big coincidence that the seer was killed on night one.

Of course, if I was in your position, I wouldn't reveal my mystic abilities either. :)

A kill on a guarded player or Tough player will just be reported as unsuccessful.

Wha? YOU HAVE BEEN A BAD PUPPY! TAKE THAT! AND THAT!

There. I trust no more wolves will come after this villager. And I AM a villager.

Abe, my biggest ping from you was advocating the tie vote. I acknowledge that you might have just gotten your rules criscrossed from last game, but I also think you could have been floating it to see if the people in there before deadline didn't know the rules and possibly get a double whammy. I admit it's not the best theory I've ever had.

Feel like crap with more crap on it. Ugh.

Simbo, Abe is a smart cookie with extra smart on it. I don't think he would be confused about rules altho he may do things for either strategic or silly reasons.

i feel like I"m talking to shiggles :)
Or maybe all newcomers RP and act silly until they get all their joy in life drained out of them.

Ooooooh Abe! YOu're so saxy when you're first!

I read (and am a big fan of) a lot of his stuff in the dynasty section, and of course got massacred in his Dungeon. That's why I felt like it was unusual for him not to know, he seems to be someone who is quite up with the rules.

Jeebus 24 bots in the thread.

bringing this over to the new page

1 - CrimsonFox: mauboy (#319, #336)
1 - Suicane: booradley (#320)
1 - Abe: simbo klice (#331)
1 - booradley: suicane (#337)

Pot? Meet Kettle?

I am surprised CF hasn't posted "Hi Bots!!!" yet.

At least that's a reason.

I'm not that smart

Quite so.

Alright, time for the voting. I'm not voting for myself, and I'm certainly not adding a fifth name to the pie.

So, I shall be the first to cast a second vote on someone today, since it seems like everyone else is avoiding it. Silly WW players!


I think boo's vote lacked a lot of credibility.


vote booradley

I know booradley is a new player, but this kind of screams I am not a wolf look the other way type of post. That combined with his weird exchange with sucaine is where I am going to place my vote for now.

It is not much to go on, I realize this. But I can't really justify any of the other candidates and I don't think we need a fifth one either.

VOTE BOORADLEY

Couldn't disagree more. It's the quiet ones you need to look out for. Ergo, I'm not switching off Suicane unless necessary to defend myself.

glad to see a solid turn out

But you have been just as quiet as he has been, other than today. But I am not voting for you because you have been quiet, so that is really not relevant.

his reaction to boobradley's posts pinged my radar just a little.

VOTE CRIMSON FOX

I may be ready to stick my toe back in the water soon

VOTE LATHUM!

That would be great, Lathum. I wouldn't have to think about my Day 1 votes anymore.

unvote Suicane

Vote Crimson Fox

Self-preservation. In all candor, I am a villager, guys.

3 - CrimsonFox: mauboy (#319, #336), daddytorgo (#372), booradley (#376)
1 - Abe: simbo klice (#331)
3 - booradley: suicane (#337), abe (#367), golden eagle (#368)

a tie (for the moment)

Choices, choices.

I had a thought, seeing as we're in D3 and don't have a real idea where we're going. What if we created a CoT by outing the BG and the hunter? It sounds crazy, I know. But if the BG's able to protect himself tonight, it'll take the wolves 3 days to kill off the 2 villagers. Given that a BG's chance of getting a block is 1/(number of players), keeping the wolves to 2/3 isn't a bad deal for the village. And it could give us some idea of who to go after (narrowing the field from 10 to 8 and illuminating the record of known villagers to perhaps point out wolves by their differences).

It could take 4 nights to kill them of, as a matter of fact, if the BG wins the silent face-off on who to protect between himself and the hunter, or if the wolves get themselves caught up in that chess match.

Not sure that's the best idea. We don't have anybody else to add to that CoT based on events at the moment.

No kill last night means a BG block or a hunter, right? Or i suppose a missed night order.

So if those 2 out themselves then the wolves will know which role they attacked last night, and therefore if it was a BG block or a hunter-attack, and it will help them narrow down their choice of a night kill tonight and going forward.

If the two don't reveal then the wolves won't know which they were the victim of, and thus it leaves them with some uncertainty about what they should do.

Not sure how much of a help their being worried is, but it's better then them being sure.

Everyone always wants to out arole if they aren;t one.... I remember being BAtman and everyone wanted me to come out.

Fair points.

I thought about it earlier also -- but I think it's a day too soon yet. It could be pretty vital if the wolves know which is which and would confirm what they did last night and they'd be able to key on what was done last night and get a sure NK tonight. Then we also deal with the cultist likely fake revealing once one of them comes out...

Not today, for sure.

Looks like there's at least one CF and boo voter in the thread. Any of you care to share a rationale with me? I don't have an inclination yet.

CF's response to boo tweaked my radar a little - he said something about new players acting a certain way until they were "drained" I think. It's not much, but it seemed like one of those things that CF should have known would get a response.

There was something the CF said early on in the game (day two, since I was gone for day one...lol) that seemed like a plant to me for future use to frame me as a wolf. Just pinged me. Gut feeling, no more, no less.

That is a really bad idea, especially the hunter. The wolves have a pretty big advantage right now. If they get the hunter, it is going to be really tough for us to win.

This kind of seems like a wolf play to me. The wolves have a big advantage right now and getting the hunter to come out would be huge for them.

Update - still

3 - CrimsonFox: mauboy (#319, #336), daddytorgo (#372), booradley (#376)
1 - Abe: simbo klice (#331)
3 - booradley: suicane (#337), abe (#367), golden eagle (#368)

In response to GE: a point I hadn't thought of is that when the wolves are finally able to kill off the hunter, they'll be doubly rewarded, as the hunter counts for 2 in the V:W ratio. So I'll back off that idea altogether.

Just woke up from a nap. Gee again? I am a villager.

This "pinging stuff" is annoying. It was just a phrase as his posts reminded me of shiggles during his first game. NOthing more. All this picking apart stuff from you and mauboy.

I was making fun of you for forgetting to log in again if that's what happened. The second post was part making fun/part observational as I've seen people use that as wolves before plenty of times and am not phased by it.

Hmm... gut feelings... I trust mau, who seems more talkative than normal. I trust Abe, though I'm not sure exactly why. I was leery of GE, but by poking at my reveal idea, he seems more trustworthy.

mau and Abe's votes landed on DT yesterday while mau, DT, and CF were in that little dance I described earlier. But CF doesn't trust DT and mau. Meanwhile, GE voted for me.

Conclusions? Hard to come by. But right now, I'm thinking mau and DT may be working together, GE is suspicious of me because I play in a way that draws suspicion from him, and CF, while not using as many emoticons as he sometimes does, strikes me as okay.

Collaterally, I'll side with CF and GE and

VOTE booradley

That's fine then.. at this point someone needs to be lynched. Perhaps I will switch off you, I don't know. I certainly am not going to let a tie happen.

All this 'trust' talk makes me think suspiciously of you!

would love to vote mau or dt right now or an utr, but gotta save myself. granted i don't know what to make of boo yet so he could easily be wolfy

VOTE BOO

3 - CrimsonFox: mauboy (#319, #336), daddytorgo (#372), booradley (#376)
1 - Abe: simbo klice (#331)
4 - booradley: suicane (#337), abe (#367), golden eagle (#368), britrock88 (#395)

wow all you people typing when i'm typing and being faster at the reply button...