Front Office Football Central

Front Office Football Central (https://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//index.php)
-   Off Topic (https://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   POTUS 2024 - Harris vs Trump - General Election Discussion (https://forums.operationsports.com/fofc//showthread.php?t=99329)

Lathum 07-25-2024 09:26 PM

OK.

But just know I am better than you

Lathum 07-25-2024 09:26 PM

That was sarcasm BTW

JPhillips 07-25-2024 09:42 PM

Yikes. JD is 16 points underwater in favorability in the midwest.

NobodyHere 07-25-2024 11:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian Swartz (Post 3438056)
The amusing part to me:

- People make false accusations about Harris: disgusting, how dare they (this is the correct response)
- People make false accusations about Vance: lol that's hilarious.

:banghead: :banghead: :banghead:


Honestly, the Vance couch stuff is hilarious.

You are right that it is wrong to make false accusations about someone, especially of a sexual nature.

But I personally don't pretend that I'm a good person.

JPhillips 07-25-2024 11:06 PM

This guy is good.


cuervo72 07-25-2024 11:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438041)
Mostly agree. It's just a list of things conservatives have talked about for decades. And the Heritage Foundation has lost most of its influence in Washington so it's funny to see them being trotted out as a boogeyman.

With that said, it's incredibly fucking stupid to put all your unpopular ideas like that down on a document that can be shared. Can't blame the Democrats for taking advantage of that massive blunder.


They're still a bit disconcerting though. And as has been said, it's not like they haven't had any wins.


RainMaker 07-25-2024 11:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JPhillips (Post 3438102)
This guy is good.



Yeah, he's really good. Democrats have a stable of savvy Governors that were being blocked out by the old guard. I think people will be surprised if they get more publicity.


RainMaker 07-26-2024 12:21 AM

lol I think she has a shot


Ghost Econ 07-26-2024 06:47 AM

The Rand Corporation, in conjunction with the saucer people, under the supervision of the reverse vampires are forcing our parents to go to bed early in a fiendish plot to eliminate the meal of dinner.




Vegas Vic 07-26-2024 09:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438105)
lol I think she has a shot


Right now, it's probably fairly close to a coin flip, which is remarkable considering where this thing stood after that disastrous Biden debate performance.

These state polls are what to keep an eye on, especially Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. The national polls aren't meaningless, but keep in mind that she needs to be up by about 4 points or more in the popular vote to translate into an electoral college lead.

flere-imsaho 07-26-2024 10:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438094)
Doing the debate so early with Biden and picking Vance as VP will go down as two of the biggest blunders in American political history.


Not if Trump wins.

flere-imsaho 07-26-2024 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vegas Vic (Post 3438116)
These state polls are what to keep an eye on, especially Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. The national polls aren't meaningless, but keep in mind that she needs to be up by about 4 points or more in the popular vote to translate into an electoral college lead.


Going to quote this for importance. I've seen a lot about how engagement for Democrats is up among minorities and young people, and that's great. But this isn't about running up the vote in New York, California, and Illinois. She needs to win some group of Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Nevada, North Carolina, Arizona.

Since 1992, the Democratic candidate has won the popular vote in every GE except 2004. It's not about how many votes you get, it's where you get those votes.

albionmoonlight 07-26-2024 10:48 AM

Predict it has it at 56/47 Trump right now, which feels about right.

Pretty much a coin flip with a slight Trump edge.

We don't know how many quiet old white Biden voters there are in the Midwest who aren't going to blindly jump on the Harris bandwagon.

cartman 07-26-2024 10:55 AM

The Obamas have officially endorsed Kamala.

Ksyrup 07-26-2024 10:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flere-imsaho (Post 3438119)
Going to quote this for importance. I've seen a lot about how engagement for Democrats is up among minorities and young people, and that's great. But this isn't about running up the vote in New York, California, and Illinois. She needs to win some group of Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Nevada, North Carolina, Arizona.

Since 1992, the Democratic candidate has won the popular vote in every GE except 2004. It's not about how many votes you get, it's where you get those votes.


Positive news in Michigan:

Harris, Trump tied in Michigan survey

I can't recall where I read it, but someone posted that Trump was +8 in the last poll. Not sure if that's accurate or not, though.

flere-imsaho 07-26-2024 11:11 AM

It's not particularly meaningful unless it's the last poll by the same pollster.

albionmoonlight 07-26-2024 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cartman (Post 3438122)
The Obamas have officially endorsed Kamala.


That might be the final nail in Marianne Williamson's coffin.

RainMaker 07-26-2024 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flere-imsaho (Post 3438117)
Not if Trump wins.


Of course, but this race went from a Trump cakewalk to a coin flip in about a week. If Trump holds off on the debate till after the convention, Dems are stuck with Biden.

RainMaker 07-26-2024 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vegas Vic (Post 3438116)
Right now, it's probably fairly close to a coin flip, which is remarkable considering where this thing stood after that disastrous Biden debate performance.

These state polls are what to keep an eye on, especially Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. The national polls aren't meaningless, but keep in mind that she needs to be up by about 4 points or more in the popular vote to translate into an electoral college lead.


I think a lot of the statistical folks who pour over data have said that's no longer the case. That there is actually a decent chance that Trump wins the popular vote but loses the electoral college.

Maybe that changes with Kamala but Biden's strategy was to alienate the base to hopefully snag enough white men in the Rust Belt to win. His support in solid blue states was down from your typical Democratic candidate.

There was also a Georgia poll that had Trump up 1 only, but it showed Kamala with over 30% of the white vote. If a Democrat gets over 30% in Georgia, I've seen all the stat folks say she'll win the state barring a huge dropoff in black voters.

albionmoonlight 07-26-2024 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438129)
There was also a Georgia poll that had Trump up 1 only, but it showed Kamala with over 30% of the white vote. If a Democrat gets over 30% in Georgia, I've seen all the stat folks say she'll win the state barring a huge dropoff in black voters.


I saw something once that if a Dem could ever get 25% of the White vote in Mississippi, they would win. Crazy stat.

Atocep 07-26-2024 01:57 PM

The voting demographics have shifted somewhat substantially over the past 4 years. Baby Boomers are passing away and the GOP has done nothing to appeal to young voters replacing them that aren't fueled by racism.

It's anyone's guess until we see the results but I don't think the GOP has the same advantages they previously had. Polling right now is also more likely to overstate GOP support rather than Dems because some assumptions are being made by pollsters trying to figure out Trump's support and making some guesses at what the electoral demographics will look like.

What should worry Trump, now that Biden isn't on the ticket, is nearly every state poll in the primaries overshot his support prior to the primary.

thesloppy 07-26-2024 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Atocep (Post 3438132)
It's anyone's guess until we see the results but I don't think the GOP has the same advantages they previously had. Polling right now is also more likely to overstate GOP support rather than Dems because some assumptions are being made by pollsters trying to figure out Trump's support and making some guesses at what the electoral demographics will look like.


That's how I feel as well. I've been pretty vocal about how I don't trust the newly 'adjusted' polling methods for the Presidential race, but I DO trust the movement of those polls. Like I don't trust the baseline they're starting from, but if that number shifts 10 points in one direction that significant movement is a legit indicator, regardless of the accuracy of the starting point.

flere-imsaho 07-26-2024 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438129)
I think a lot of the statistical folks who pour over data have said that's no longer the case. That there is actually a decent chance that Trump wins the popular vote but loses the electoral college.


I'd like to see this, because I doubt this very much. Given the way the electoral college is structured, I'm not sure it is possible for a GOP candidate to win the popular vote but lose the EC.

Danny 07-26-2024 02:35 PM

If they get rising support in big blue states. Theres definitely still a trump segment here in California.

thesloppy 07-26-2024 02:42 PM

"JD Vance searched for interspecies dolphin sex, and
then admitted it on Twitter"


https://www.rawstory.com/jd-vance-dolphin-search-history/

Ksyrup 07-26-2024 03:08 PM

I was half-expecting to see a picture of Jim McElwain and a shark.

Arles 07-26-2024 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438128)
Of course, but this race went from a Trump cakewalk to a coin flip in about a week. If Trump holds off on the debate till after the convention, Dems are stuck with Biden.

If Trump doesn't have an assassination attempt, the Dems are probably stuck with Biden. The bad polls are what hurt Biden and they didn't really get ugly until Mid July. In April, Trump had a 2-point lead. In early July, the aggregate was around +2.3, it wasn't until after July 13 that the damn broke to +3.5.

flere-imsaho 07-26-2024 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danny (Post 3438136)
If they get rising support in big blue states. Theres definitely still a trump segment here in California.


But the same demographic that would "rise" in CA (or IL, or NY, etc...) is also going to be present in swing states. Every time someone digs deep into this they say something like (this is a totally made up example) "young latino men will come out in force for Trump in CA even though it won't make a difference" but then young latino men will also come out in force in Arizona where it will.

I'd love to see a Trump-supporting demographic that a) we expect to expand in voting participation this election and b) is mainly confined to solid blue states.

Arles 07-26-2024 04:00 PM

I'll be interested in where everything is in September. I think June to early July was the best possible set of circumstances for Trump (Hunter trial, bad Biden debate, failed assassination) and late July has been the best set of circumstances for Harris (great fundraising, everyone falling in line, even Beyonce doing an ad for her!).

I don't think Trump was going to keep his lead from early July no matter what so I will be interested to see how the ads and machines work in August for both parties. I do think this will be a close election, there's just so much noise on both sides with this much time left.

I think one big advantage for Harris is she will only be campaigning for a little over three months before people vote. There hasn't been enough time for the right to chip away at her and do what they did to Hillary (massive 18 month onslaught). If the Dems can properly frame Harris quickly as a good alternative to the two old guys, I think she could win. They need to be aggressive though. The flip side is if they just rely on positive media coverage and let the Trump goons flood TVs with attack ads on her (a la Hillary), the opposite could happen. This is like a court trial where the republicans are trying to sew "reasonable doubt" in white voters on Harris and her team needs to be ready to fight this. And, yes, I know my analogy is reversed to real life where Trump is the felon and Harris is the prosecutor :D

albionmoonlight 07-26-2024 04:38 PM

That makes sense, Arles.

If you think about it, the GOP had been chipping away at Hillary since 1992.

GrantDawg 07-26-2024 04:38 PM

lol...

GrantDawg 07-26-2024 05:26 PM

FBI report says what hit Trump in the ear was a bullet, whether whole or fragmented.

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk

RainMaker 07-26-2024 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arles (Post 3438147)
I'll be interested in where everything is in September. I think June to early July was the best possible set of circumstances for Trump (Hunter trial, bad Biden debate, failed assassination) and late July has been the best set of circumstances for Harris (great fundraising, everyone falling in line, even Beyonce doing an ad for her!).

I don't think Trump was going to keep his lead from early July no matter what so I will be interested to see how the ads and machines work in August for both parties. I do think this will be a close election, there's just so much noise on both sides with this much time left.

I think one big advantage for Harris is she will only be campaigning for a little over three months before people vote. There hasn't been enough time for the right to chip away at her and do what they did to Hillary (massive 18 month onslaught). If the Dems can properly frame Harris quickly as a good alternative to the two old guys, I think she could win. They need to be aggressive though. The flip side is if they just rely on positive media coverage and let the Trump goons flood TVs with attack ads on her (a la Hillary), the opposite could happen. This is like a court trial where the republicans are trying to sew "reasonable doubt" in white voters on Harris and her team needs to be ready to fight this. And, yes, I know my analogy is reversed to real life where Trump is the felon and Harris is the prosecutor :D


Hillary had like 20+ years of being a repulsive human being. She was wrong on almost every single issue. It wasn't some Trump attacks that did her in, it was that she was a bad candidate that people didn't like.

The difference in now and 2016 is that Trump is more unpopular than he was before. His mere presence riles up voters. And he can no longer run on the "outsider" platform that worked in 2016.

Maybe I'm overly optimistic on Harris' chance, but I feel like she has a lot in her favor. Republicans and Trump are inherently unpopular. Their ideas are weird and people don't like them (his candidates lost every swing state in 2022). Harris doesn't need to be a great candidate, just someone who can speak on how weird Trump, make abortion a central issue, and act like a normal human being.

GrantDawg 07-26-2024 09:03 PM

From what I have seen, she has definitely energized people. My timeline is full of people who had said they would never vote for Biden that are now all in on Kamala.

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk

RainMaker 07-26-2024 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Arles (Post 3438144)
If Trump doesn't have an assassination attempt, the Dems are probably stuck with Biden. The bad polls are what hurt Biden and they didn't really get ugly until Mid July. In April, Trump had a 2-point lead. In early July, the aggregate was around +2.3, it wasn't until after July 13 that the damn broke to +3.5.


Biden was getting clobbered all the way back to 2023 if you look at the swing states. He shit on his base hard to defend Israel and it cost him dearly. The debate was the last straw as it solidified every negative point against him.

It's also coming out that his campaign didn't know what the fuck they were doing. They didn't run internal polling for 2 months. They had no ads running on social media. And his advisors kept telling him to talk up his foreign policy which was disastrous instead of focusing on abortion. Just a clusterfuck and I think we'll get some eye-opening books some day about his administration.

Danny 07-26-2024 09:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GrantDawg (Post 3438165)
From what I have seen, she has definitely energized people. My timeline is full of people who had said they would never vote for Biden that are now all in on Kamala.

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk



For sure. I still would have voted Biden 100% against Trump but I didnt really feel good about supporting his run for a second term.

RainMaker 07-26-2024 09:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flere-imsaho (Post 3438146)
But the same demographic that would "rise" in CA (or IL, or NY, etc...) is also going to be present in swing states. Every time someone digs deep into this they say something like (this is a totally made up example) "young latino men will come out in force for Trump in CA even though it won't make a difference" but then young latino men will also come out in force in Arizona where it will.

I'd love to see a Trump-supporting demographic that a) we expect to expand in voting participation this election and b) is mainly confined to solid blue states.


Here's a pretty good breakdown of the advantage Republicans had shrinking. There are others who have talked about it (Silver, ettingermentum) too.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/11/u...rump-2024.html

What it boils down to is Republicans are making gains with minorities. But minorities make up a higher percentage in states that are not competitive. For instance, the 5 states with the highest population of Hispanic voters are California, Texas, Florida, Illinois, and New York. So if Republicans pick up a couple points in those states, it doesn't change the result, but it's millions of votes difference.

In the same vain, Democrats have been making gains with white voters. It's why Biden was able to carry Minnesota, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin that have some of the highest percentage of white voters in the country. Gaining a couple percentage points helps in the electoral college, but not so much in the popular vote since those states are smaller.

This was a trend in 2022. Whether this changes with Kamala on the ticket is another story. But Biden's best path to winning was sneaking out wins in PA, WI, and MI which would have still not gotten him enough to win the popular vote considering how poorly he was doing even in deep blue states.

GrantDawg 07-26-2024 09:37 PM

These are interesting numbers....
https://x.com/yashar/status/18170109...ifKfkl4vw&s=19

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk

JPhillips 07-26-2024 09:42 PM

I wonder if Trump's numbers are still be bolstered by people who didn't vote in 2022 or 2020.

JPhillips 07-26-2024 09:52 PM

dola

I mean Trump is the one saying stuff like this:

Quote:

Trump: You have to get out and vote. You won’t have to do it anymore. Four years, it will be fixed, it will be fine. You won’t have to vote anymore.. In four years, you won’t have to vote again.

thesloppy 07-26-2024 09:53 PM




Not a single Black voter in Michigan poll says they'll back Trump - Raw Story

RainMaker 07-26-2024 10:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GrantDawg (Post 3438171)
These are interesting numbers....
x.com


Shapiro helps in Pennsylvania but I think might hurt elsewhere. I'm sure they have run the numbers though to decide if he's worth the risk.

GrantDawg 07-27-2024 08:42 AM

Andy Beshear is headlining a campaign rally in Atlanta this weekend. There are lots of big hitter politicians putting a full court press on to try to get the VP pick.

Sent from my SM-S916U using Tapatalk

flere-imsaho 07-27-2024 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RainMaker (Post 3438170)
Here's a pretty good breakdown of the advantage Republicans had shrinking. There are others who have talked about it (Silver, ettingermentum) too.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/11/u...rump-2024.html


That's fine, and I was aware of that, but I see no evidence that Trump can/will win the popular vote but not win the electoral college, which was your original claim/suggestion.

And this is important because regardless of the result people really need to understand how badly the EC disadvantages democratic POTUS candidates.

Dutch 07-27-2024 02:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flere-imsaho (Post 3438200)
That's fine, and I was aware of that, but I see no evidence that Trump can/will win the popular vote but not win the electoral college, which was your original claim/suggestion.

And this is important because regardless of the result people really need to understand how badly the EC disadvantages democratic POTUS candidates.


And people really need to understand the great compromise the smaller states agreed to in order for the Union to be formed. It will always be advantageous to the smaller states because without some ability to feel represented, they would have remained simply colonies to another power.

If you ever forced a vote based on sheer population we would no longer be a Republic and would force all states to re-evaluate their entry into this Union.

The popular vote and the EC have been at odds perhaps 5 times? 6 times? So far, that’s one a helluva great result for the original compromise.

flere-imsaho 07-27-2024 03:20 PM

In 1770, the population of the smallest state, Delaware, was 8% that of the largest state, Virginia. In 2020, the population of the smallest state, Wyoming, was 1.5% that of the largest state, California.

The EC devalues the votes of millions of Americans, as done the Senate. If you truly think there's value in preserving the sovereignity of small, rural, states, then let's compromise after a quarter of a millenium and get rid of one of them.

RainMaker 07-27-2024 03:25 PM

It and the Senate were also made to protect slavery. That was what they were concerned about.

cuervo72 07-27-2024 03:27 PM

And why should that matter anymore for the presidency? Especially now? Have we asked what some of the "smaller" states think? For that matter, define "smaller"? Why is Montana a "small" state? What compromise was their entry part of, in 1889?

cuervo72 07-27-2024 03:39 PM

Or looking at it from another angle, why should you have more say in matters if you decide to move away from everyone else??

cuervo72 07-27-2024 04:02 PM

I mean, I'm sure because home state is very important electors in Delaware right now are all "YO WHAT THE SHIT, CALIFORNIA! THANKS FOR THE FRIGGIN' SCREW JOB!!"


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:59 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.