nah, no rush

:lol:

I think finding a comment of henry's to test is more useful than one for EagleFan to put that whole theory to bed but I'm not sure if that's the consensus or not. EF just made it pretty easy, though my only concern would be if he's not a "wolf" but a member of the conspiracy (I'm sure the GM's would be able to clarify if the term wolf=conspiracy for these purposes). I'll go back and try to find something testable from henry.

As a Cardinals fan, I can tell you that you are telling the truth there. :D

It is hard to find something that is agreed upon by Cubs and Cards fans, but I think we have one here. Absolutely truthful statement - soothsayer not required.

:mad:

henry, you're a cagey bastard. ;)

Not much to go on by his statements, I've bolded below the one I think is most applicable.

Too late, I already sent the PM :p (j/k)

path, this one was the one I was thinking of.

Af of 1961 (correct me if I missed anything):

Thom 5 (31%) - henry (1711), PB (1713), king (1746), saldana (1758), ntn (1762)
henry 1 (6%) - EF (1783)
EF 2 (13%)- DT (1850), IS (1917)


Yet to vote:
TheJackal, Passacaglia, Autumn, Schmidty, BrianD, nfg22, Thomkal, path12

That's a good one too because it gets me off the list. :)

I've never had a soothsayer role before. I don't think it would play to my strengths.

Now that I think about it, there's not much about WW that plays to my strengths.

I bet the Plutonium role would have been right in your wheelhouse, path.

Checking in here-I'm not likely to be around much this afternoon, but wanted to state that I stand by what I said yesterday after the lynch-I voted for Jackal because he was another suspect on Danny's list, a list and theory I agreed with. There were already votes on his #1 suspect, nfg, so didn't want to create a runaway vote on him.

I also thought Danny was being played by the wolves when he said he got a PM saying Chief Rum was evil just as there was going to be enough votes to lynch Telle. Therefore I did not move to Chief Rum and was waiting to see if the person who gave him the information came forward so I could believe his claim more strongly. That info did not come out, so I stayed where I was. I should have moved to Telle from Jackal I guess, but that likely would have made me suspect anyway since Telle has been revealed as a government worker. It was just poor judgement on my part, not anything wolfy.

The above is the one thing that makes me doubt my Thomkal vote. I thought Danny was being played as well by somebody trying to make a late push at saving somebody so I didn't move off of Telle. For now, I'll stay where I'm at but am open to some of our other options as well.

I woulda kicked ass with the Clock as well. Poli keeps missing the second beat.

I can't see voting for someone because they didn't move to Telle. Obviously no one should have moved to Telle. Reading it after the fact I didn't really understand the surge, and if it wasn't for Henry's reveal I'd be assuming it was done by a pack of wolves. I can sympathize with EF's doubts because it seems impossible to think there's not a wolf in there on a runaway on a random villager.

There is also a heartbeat sound that is behind the tick/beep sound that has never been very well represented by the clock.

There have not been any silent clocks, no split-screens focusing in on the characters, no speeding up of the clock at any point, no sound of crashing glass ... bottom line, I think that the clock role has been butchered all game long.

I've been looking back at posts from this list. If you go back to yesterday and relook at the Thomkal/Danny interactions during the day it does not look nearly as damning as Danny thought it did in the moment (to me, anyway).

I'm also willing to give king a day or two to see how that whole nfg thing works out. I do not get a bad vibe from EagleFan.

My vote will most likely be from this group: Jackal, ISiddiqui and Autumn.

Going through back posts is so much easier with the low posters.

Don't you hate designing a role and seeing it go so horribly, horribly wrong?

We haven't talked about this much, but the clock role was my baby (plutonium was hoops') and so it is I who is suffering here path.

This was an incredibly insightful comment. I'm convinced Jackal is good now.

I kid.

I'm sorry to hear that, BK. The anguish shows in your comment.

I think you're getting short shrift here BTW for your efforts. I want you to know that I see both you and hoops as a giant combined galaxy of GMness and appreciate your efforts.

Oh, how did the over/under of 3 on the PM box clearance turn out?

I had to empty my box twice yesterday. In other words, over in a landslide. Just like I predicted. Alas I couldn't get anyone to actually book the bet.

Add Schmidty to the list of my possible votes.

One thing that worries me about these statements, EF, is that you say wolf instead of conspiracy in a lot of them.

So basically: My last two games:

1) I pick up on PB as a potential wolf based on a move he makes then pick up on Lathum as a potential convert. Neither gets listened to. End results, PB wolf, Lathum convert.

2) I pick up on a play that I believe is being made by the cunning in the reveal game. Same result with no one listening. End result, dead on accurate.

Now I am concerned about a potential traitor play but again no one seems to want to entertain that thought. I hope for our sake that I am wrong. People wonder why I am frustrated?

Part of that problem is that I don;t know what the cunning role is so how accurate is cunning conspirator. I'll make a few more with conspiracy in place.



I have no idea what the cunning role's PM says.

I have no idea what the conspiracy roles' PM's say.

I am not in the conspiracy.



Anything else that you would like?

The Penguins will not make the Stanley Cup finals next year.

Sidney Crosby is a wuss.

The Yankees suck!!!

"Big Ben" did not get that ball across the goal line.

Manny Ramirez is a cheating punk.

Corzine is an idiot who is out of touch with the real world.

What worries me with your statements here EF is that you are obviously delusional and simply trying to hurt me. :(

No hurt intended.

:devil:

Ok. I've a lot of the past few pages, even though it looks it's a tag-along vote, I'm still going with Thomkal unless someone can give me a reason not to.

not unless he's the cunning.

did you get a reply?

or wait - were you testing henry?

*confusion reigns in my brain*

ISidiqqui - i didn't get a chance to look at PM's from earlier in the game - this has turned into the busy-friday from hell. i will look after work

I went with EF instead, and got a reply.

[quote=DaddyTorgo;2069792ISidiqqui - i didn't get a chance to look at PM's from earlier in the game - this has turned into the busy-friday from hell. i will look after work[/quote]

Can understand that entirely :D.

Hey, sometimes I gotta work too ;).

!!:rant:

dammit, quote box :mad:

I just meant that while I was under pressure, I was finally asked to vote for who I thought was a wolf, ignoring any self-defense voting or whatever, and I voted for CR. Fairly early. My vote was on him most of the day, and I only switched off because no one was really taking a CR vote seriously until Danny's reveal. In the meantime CR and I had agreed to switch to Telle in the thread (kind of a bad idea for two wolves to communicate like that, wouldn't you say?) so as to save ourselves, and I agreed since I had some suspicion on Telle, though I think I even noted I thought it was likelier CR was a wolf. And look what happened - CR is a wolf.

Even Danny, who was probably the hardest after me said after the lynch that he thought I was probably telling the truth.

What do I have to do? I understand if we get near the end and there's 1-2 wolves left and I'm still uncleared (which I hope isn't the case), but when there's still around 4, I'm really the first person you're going to go after?

Still catching up, just responding to posts as I go.

But the time is not moving... :)

Care to elaborate? I call BS.

I am not a wolf.

These I agree with!

So, Pass just did a one line vote after supposedly using his soothsayer ability?

Put my theory to the test. It's all I ask and I have asked so little this game.

What do you want, a five paragraph essay?

You even voted him before I did on Day 3 and he was up to 5 votes including danny (good), PB (good via henry), jackal (put CR up by one with his vote, I presume good), and myself

Unvote Thomkal
Vote Autumn

Let's go back to early on. Autumn PM'd two government agents, nfg (who we know is good now with henry's intel) and myself, asking for our character names with DT mentioned in the PM as well.

Good play for a wolf as if they wound a character name that they liked they could have easily killed them off and took over that persona.

Also Autumn didn't vote for CR.