I would hope that we would see something like this. Inactivity breeds suspicion so, just a lack of vote would raise some eyebrows.

Airhog says Neuqua is going to be killed and then no kill? Make sense for the bodyguard to guard Neuqua in case the wolves were setting up Airhog. Of course, that just seems all too obvious but, would account for no killings yet.

We either have a really good bodyguard, some extra wolves running around or some really lazy or cunning wolves running around.

Yes, you would be notified if the doctor saved someone.

Which raises the question, assuming Nequa was the one protected and the wolves tried to eat him, was it Airhog that tried to eat him, or is it the wolves are trying to set Airhog up? It does seem interesting that Airhog says Nequa is going to get eaten, then no one dies. However, it seems crazy to announce who you're going to eat ahead of time, even as a joke. I'd like to hear what he has to say.

I can assure you, if you lynch me, I will not die!

The Duke?

Huh?

Oh yeah. Forgot about the Duke.

He's already said he's the werewolf. Now he's claiming he's the Duke??

Because you cannot kill a werewolf! :P

Does seem crazy and risky and high unlikely... which then again is the perfect time to do that. Of course, this comes from a person that thought BrianD was lying about being a seer in the last game. :D

Perhaps Airhog did try to eat Neuqua and he was the cursed one. It would make sense for no one being eatin and now there is one more werewolf? For now I am sticking with my vote for Airhog, but I may need to rethink it.

Can the Duke save himself? That wasn't addressed in the rules.

I already said I didn't think Airhog was a WW. But now he's just starting to bug me. It is plausible though that he is the duke. That might have given him the stones to come out and say he was a WW, just to mess with us.

Hmmmm....

Yes, the Duke can save himself. That should have been in the role explanation but I may have left it out, I'll edit it back in.

Im not the duke, Im just the brutal wolf.

then you can be killed.

You have an intriguing strategy, Airhog.

You are the Duke of Hawthorne Manor! You are A number one!!

But I don't think it's going to work.

I have no idea what Airhog is playing at, but he seems crazy enough.

I vote Airhog

It's funny because I was kicking around a role, which I decided not to use this game, called the Lunatic, which was a person driven crazy by the stresses of werewolves and being lynched. Maybe Airhog broke into my notes! ;)

Sure asking to be killed... why, I have noooo idea. :confused:


follow up - Although, maybe he did break into Peregrine's notes. Sure would explain alot. :D

Hehe.

Now that would be a fun role to have!

Einnie, Minnie, Miney, Mo,
Catch a Dukie by the Toe,
If you lynch him he will say,
Tis not the duke who'll die today.

He might just point at one of you,
Since you fingered him with much ado,
It wont be long before your dead,
And the Duke will sleep soundly in his bed.

I think your rhythm is a little off.

Hey its kind hard for a crazy wolf pretending to be the duke to write poems

Going through the thread there are some interesting posts:


And later




Odd that Airhog's name comes up so early in a random post. Maybe just a coincidence.

Well, the way I figure it right now is either Airhog is potentially a Werewolf or the Duke...

If he is the Duke and we do lynch him, he will get pretty much a random shot in the dark to kill a Werewolf. Bad thing is, if he is the duke... and chooses poorly that means it has outted him, killed another villager and will allow the werewolves to kill a separate villager tonight. Thats a swing of 3 villagers (2 dead, 1 known and with his special powers gone..)

If you are the Duke Airhog, hope you are reallllllly sure of what you are doing. Just seems like a wasted opportunity...

Do you hope that I am really sure of what I am doing if I am the werewolf?

There is a part of me that wonders if Airhog is either the Sorcerer or a Cultist trying to make sure we lynch him and not a wolf. It is a good way to help the wolves, though he wouldn't be able to claim a win if he is dead.

I just threw a name in as an example of a person that it wouldn't make sense for the bodyguard to protect the first night because there was no history of anyone else other than those that played the first game.

Plus, I stated that I would pick someone that wasn't active.. which, at the time was Airhog.

It seems a little early to pull out that strategy though

edit: meaning BrianD's

Perhaps the wolves tried to eat Airhog but he turned into the cursed wolf. Now maybe he is trying to sabotage the wolves by having them lose their new wolf.

Or maybe he's fucked up

Not sure what the point of playing would be then to mess everyone up and cause your side to potentially lose? :confused:

Here is every post I have made so far, for easy reference ;)


You know some of us do have jobs I havent even been on until 5 minutes ago. Nice to see people voting for me only on the basis of that 1 item. Of course, this early in the game you are really just shooting blanks here. I havent had time to properly read this thread so I am witholding a vote for now, besides I need to go cook some huma...err chicken for dinner.

Personally I dont think the werewolf would be so vocal in the beginning. I think the werewolf would be someone that would join the bandwagon so to speak. They want to try to draw the least amount of attention to themselves. Also, I dont think the wolves would vote for the same person unless that person was already getting alot of vote.

I knew Shorty wasn't a werewolf. However someone had to be lynched this first day without any sort of clues to go on. It's really a coin toss as to who to choose. No hard feelings Desnudo. I didnt vote for you to be lynched because I thought you were a werewolf, so much as a didnt think Shorty or Nomyths was one. I guess I could have abstained from the vote, but that might have been construed as being suspicious.

Because im the werewolf!

Yeah, and I plan on eating Neuqua next!

I am not a werewolf. I may be a hunter, a seer, an bodyguard, a werewolf, but I am not a porn star.

I can't wait to see who gets killed tonight

Most interesting, maybe someone has a secret angel watching above them. Either that, or one of the bodyguards chose to protect the one who should have been eaten. Interesting indeed.

I can assure you, if you lynch me, I will not die!

Because you cannot kill a werewolf! :P

Im not the duke, Im just the brutal wolf.

Einnie, Minnie, Miney, Mo,
Catch a Dukie by the Toe,
If you lynch him he will say,
Tis not the duke who'll die today.

He might just point at one of you,
Since you fingered him with much ado,
It wont be long before your dead,
And the Duke will sleep soundly in his bed.

Hey its kind hard for a crazy wolf pretending to be the duke to write poems

Do you hope that I am really sure of what I am doing if I am the werewolf?

My line of thinking there is he originally would have then been on the villagers side, and would want them to still win

I agree. I'm just trying to make sense of what he is doing.

Yeah... good luck with that.

I think my headache just came back. :(

I've been battling this one all day.. I'll log back on later to see what other roles Airhog is...

It is the only explaination that makes sense so far.

That string of gibberish (Airhog's posts) doesn't help his cause, IMO.

Q: Mommy, why do all the other Kids call me a Werewolf?
A: Stop talking and brush your face!

Q: What gift did the werewolf parents give to their son?
A: A comb !

Q: What happened when the wolf fell in the washing machine ?
A: He became a wash and werewolf !

Q: What happened to the werewlf who ate garlic ?
A: His bark was worse than his bite !

Q: Who are some of the werewolves cousins ?
A: The whatwolves and whenwolves !

Q: Where does the werewolf sit in the cinema ?
A: Anywhere he wants to !

Q: What do you get if you cross a werewolf and a frog ?
A: A creature that can bite you from the other side of the road !

Q: How do you know if a werewolf's been in the fridge ?
A: The paw prints in the butter !

Q: How do you know if two werewolves have been in the fridge ?
A: Two pairs of paw prints in the butter !


Q: What does it mean if you find a werewolf in the fridge in the morning ?
A: You had some party the night before !

Q: How do you stop a werewolf chasing you ? A: Throw a stick and say fetch !

Q: What do you get if you cross a hairdresser and a werewolf ?
A: A creature with an all over perm !

Q: What happened when the werewolf swallowed a clock ?
A: He got ticks !

Q: Why shouldn't you grab a werewolf by it's tail ?
A: It might be the werewolf's tail but it could be the end of you !

Q: Why are werewolvse thought of as quick witted ?
A: Because they always give snappy answers !

Q: Why did the parents call their child "Camera" ?
A: Because they were always snapping !

Q: What do you call a hairy beast with clothes on ?
A: A wear-wolf !

Q: What do you call a hairy beast that is lost ?
A: A where-wolf !

Q: What happens if you cross a werewolf and a sheep ?
A: You have to get a new sheep !

Q: What is fearsome, hairy and drinks from the wrong side of a glass ?
A: A werewolf with hiccups !

Q: What do you call an extinct hairy beast ?
A: A were-wolf !

Q: What do you call a dentist who cleans a werewolf's teeth?
A: CRAZY!!!!!

Q: What kind of monster is washing machine safe?
A: A wash and wear wolf

I can't wait for Airhog to get lynched just so I can see what role he has been playing.

I was informed by Comcast that my internet is going to go down for an alleged upgrade this evening and should be back by tomorrow. I don't know who I'll be voting for, but, just in case, I'll vote for Airhog .

I vote Nequa

I wasnt able to eat him, but I can try to give him a good old fashioned lynching. Then I'll eat him when no-one is looking!

Is anyone else going to be seriously annoyed if we find out that Airhog didn't have a reason for his oddness and he is just fucking around?

Maybe The Afoci hacked his account

Some people are playing this game to win. Other people are playing this game just to eat some humans. You decide which one I am doing

oooh, 3 for me and none for you!

Airhog must be a Malkavian Vampire, I just know it.

I loved all the jokes.

I just watched "Young Frankenstein" last night and I was thinking about the game when they went into the whole werewolves bit.

[wolf howl]

Inga (Terri Garr): Werewolf?! (frightened)

Frederick (Gene Wilder): Werewolves? (incredulously)

Igor (Marty Feldman): [pointing] There wolf.


I don't know Airhog's ploy, I'm amused by it, but unsure what to think about it. He definately is gaining the attention and thus keeping attention from other suspects at bay, but who do we really have as other suspects?

My whole Shorty in cahoots with BrianD theory was shot to hell once Shorty turned up human.

Sorry Shorty.

Btw I just watched the Thing tonight and I thought about the whole concept of paranoia and the game we're playing (plus last game they had some images from the movie).

In that movie, I still wonder if at the end MacReady and Childs face off, die, or actually survive (very slim). I've often wondered if Childs is an alien at the end, just resigned to the fact that they're both going to die.

I wonder more how the hell Kurt Russell would wear that hat.

I vote airhog

i want to see what role he is if not a werewolf

Qwikshot, The Thing is definitely THE classic "Werewolf" movie. Paranoia, lynching, shapechanging bad guys, etc.

I think alot of people are curious. I'd love to hear other theories but, seems everyone went from the mob rules mentality to curiousity killed the cat mentality.. (so to speak)

I vote Airhog

I'm very skeptical of Airhog's ploy, but I'll keep my reasons to myself since I'm not playing. :)

Who wouldn't be?

Vote tally

Airhog - 10 (TazFTW, KevinNU7, Eaglesfan27, NoMyths, Lathum, George W Bush, BrianD, KWhit, condors, Mustang)

Neuqua - 1 (Airhog)

I vote for Airhog

I am confused about which role could benifit from drawing the attention his way this early.

I'll throw out the idea of carrying out an early lynching, since it's very obvious who it's going to be. I don't usually like the idea of lynching before the deadline (though it is done in some games) but since it's already 11 votes for Airhog and no one shows any signs of changing their votes I'm open to the option if people want to do it.

early lynching!

In Airhog's defense, I wouldn't do it too early just in case there are people that change their mind. Plus, it might not matter to do it early if the roleplayers are thinking they need to come back on later tonight so, we still might be delayed.

Yeah I will wait for some more votes to be cast in any case, there are several non-voters still so another bandwagon could form.

It doesnt look good for ole Airhog. If its not a lynching, then I am sure I will be eaten this next night. So lets just see how this plays out.

Im surprised none of my furry friends have came to help me. Why havent you tried to sway the vote yet? Do you really want to give one of your own yet? Sure I may have been cursed, and I am kinda new at this whole eating people thing. But don't leave me to be hanged!

I really don't think it's Airhog.

I worry that if Airhog is the duke, he will randomly pick one of the accusers and put him to the rope.

I worry that if Airhog is the wolf, then I will be accused for helping subvert from voting him dead.

I worry that if I don't believe Airhog is a wolf, and vote for someone else, that I may raise ire with the person I have voted to lynch be it wolf, duke, etc...

So many choices, so little time. So many risks...

On top of all that I may be eaten tonight regardless...

As a side note, real life is calling me...I will be at a birthday party after 12:30 PM E.S.T.

I should be back before votes are cast, I want to read through before making a final decision.

But this will verify my need to be inactive for a bit.

I am going to have to try and get in on this next time. This looks like my kind of fun.

On an interesting side note. If I am the duke, and I choose someone else to die in my place, who will it be?

ok well i'm going to be gone all day and back pretty late tonight

so i'll go with the mob

Vote Airhog

Since I can't see any argument to vote for someone else, Vote Airhog

I applaud you all. I firmly believe that I am cursed with lycanthropy. I also believe that Neuqa isnt one of the furry creatures. I know, because I tried to have him eaten last night, but there was a bodyguard in front of his door! I hope he doesnt take it personally, but all's fair in love, war and werewolf hunting. BriainD has been pretty vocal. I said it once, and I will say it again, I dont believe the werewolfs would single out someone different than the bandwagon, unless one of there own was under the gun. So I dont believe that Shorty, neuqua, or BriainD are werewolfs. Nomyths might be a werewolf. GWB and KevinNU7 are definately not werewolfs. So this is where I am at right now. Based on Mustangs tell, I also dont think he is a werewolf. Swaggs has been totally inactive. He hasnt even been on since the 24th. He also said he would be out of town, but he didnt pop the first vote on Shorty. I think swaggs has a speical role but im not too sure which role it is.

Unlikely to be a werewolf
Shorty
Neuqua
BrianD
KevinNU7
GWB
Mustang

Possible Werewolfs
Jon
Swaggs
TazFTW
Qwikshot
ntndeacon
McSweeny
Kwhit
Condors
Eaglesfan
Desnudo
Lathum

Well that is brilliant, youve narrowed the field of possible werewolves down to 2/3 of the players.

now, with all that being said I think it is finally time to change my vote to who I firmly believe is a werewolf.

I unvote Neuqa
I vote TazFTW

Now you guys can either A. Vote for me believe I am a werewolf
B. Change your vote and vote for someone else.
C. Vote for me believing I am the duke. If that is the case, my vote should let you know who will be taking my place tonight :)

Razzie or Oscar, I can't decide ;).

How would voting for someone else help us out? If you're Cursed, then getting rid of you kills off one of the wolves...keeping you around wouldn't. Voting for Taz wouldn't guarantee that we kill a wolf, whereas voting for you almost certainly does. I just don't see the benefit in keeping a 99% certain wolf for another chance. Besides, we can check on Taz tonight to find out if he's a wolf, unless a better candidate comes along.

If Airhog is cursed, We won't know that until the end of the game, will we. For all we kknow we have already gotten rid of a Cursed person when we lynched Shorty. Of course I am assuming that we get theidentity of the person that was sent to them. And since Cursed folks got something saying they are villagers wouldn't they appear as villagers?

Fun read. Good play by Airhog, assuming he has ousted a ww. If he hasn't, then he peaked too early!

That would be correct, if I remember it right. You only see two deaths, a villager or a werewolf. If a villager had a role, it would not be shown.

I don't care if Airhog is the Duke. If he uses his power to kill me then he will kill an innocent villager and the wolves will know Airhog is someone to eat.

hmm maybe nomyths is the seer/ He is 99% sure that I am a wolf. I wonder if he watched me last night while I was trying to eat Neuqua

Sweet. Back in town and just did the most reading that I have done since college. :)

Can we get this lynching over with already?

Unfortunately, I have to believe one of two things that I believed yesterday. Either Airhog wants us to believe he is the Duke and that Taz will be killed tonight if he is indeed the Duke and we lynch him therefore changing votes to kill Taz but, the bad thing is.. what if Airhog is a wolf trying to get us to do that?

Worst case, we could have an absolutely horrific turn of events happen if Airhog is just a normal villager and Taz is a normal villager and we swap votes... Taz would be lynched, Airhog would probably be left alone and STILL be a suspect and probably left alone by the wolves and then we start all over tomorrow with Airhog still a suspect.

Unfortunately, I feel like I'm voting for Airhog to avoid the worst case scenario in my head as opposed to if I believe he is a werewolf or not...

If my thinking is all messed up.. someone please correct me.. still have what... 4 hours to straighten this all up. :confused:

He said he was a werewolf. Why even stress out about it? If he is the Duke he will have us lynhc someone else and then the werewolves will kill him tonight. If he is a werewolf we are fine. If he is jsut a villager then he is a moron and probably just didn't want to play this game anymore

Special roles are also shown after death, it would be too confusing otherwise. Of course the Cursed is a special role where even the person who is cursed doesn't realize it unless they are killed by a werewolf, if they are lynched they would appear as a normal villager.

Sometimes, the simplest option is probably the correct one.

Ahh. I stand corrected. I could have sworn you said something about not revealing the roles at the end of the first thread.

There was some discussion about that but I decided to reveal in this game. No-reveal is still an option for future games, though it makes things a lot trickier. There's a lot more of people pretending to be one role or another.

I'm just lurking, but here's my theory about Airhog:

He's the sorceror.

He's already identified the seer, so he figures his work is done. If he can put the seer under suspicion, then he'll make the wolves' job that much easier.

Another possibility is that he's the hunter, and wants to make sure he gets a chance to kill somebody.

The possiblities are mind boggling :D

I think mustang makes a good case. I have chosen the path to walk down. Who said I wasnt enjoying this? Can you people not fathom that this is just a game and I'm having fun? Or maybe you people arent having any fun :D

My take: Airhog played the werewolf card to get a better idea on everyone else. The werewolves are like "WTF? Oh well, easy villager kill". I mean if he was a werewolf, the others wouldn't be like "Oooh, good idea! Let's waste one of our few players!"

I think Airhog is not a werewolf, just my 2 cents.

Airhog:

Why do you think Taz is a WW? What did I miss (or forget)?

Final lynching will be at 11 pm EST, the night turn players can send me their actions ahead of time if they want to speed things up a bit.

I think by now, it is indeed obvious that I am not a werewolf. I would have never intentionally tried to get myself lynched if I was, that would be a disservice to the other wolves.

March me to the gallows fellows, I am ready to die!

What is the starting Villager:Wolf ratio? Is there a set one?


I've found this entire Airhog situation quite entertaining :). I've formed my opinions, but I'm going to stay out of it.

We dont know, in a normal game the ratio is 2 wolves. however there could be as many as 4 wolves.

Yes, it's obvious you're enjoying it, since you have the most, and the longest, posts of anyone. But if I'm to change my vote, I need more information on why I should. BTW, good job on figuring out that Shorty isn't a wolf, seeing as how he's dead. ;)

If you're a good guy, then why not come clean? I'm sure the bodyguard or doctor would protect you if that's the case.

Just for fun:

I vote Airhog

Next time leave me alone! :)

I don't think Airhog is a wolf.
I don't think Airhog is the seer.

Vote Neuqua

Simply because I don't want to go with the flow.