Last game you said rule #1 is always kill Chief Rum. So I'm trying to follow your rules :)

1 Abe - JAG (48)
1 britrock - spleen (87)
1 CF - britrock (49)
1 CR - CF (51)
2 JAG - booradley (77), DT (94)
1 spleen - Suicane (97)

yet to vote: Abe, mauboy, Simbo, CR, GE, DV

Awesome, lotsa people I haven't played with before and some not for awhile. :)

hmmm rather a lot of candidates today. Any more coming?

is that a request? sounds wolfish ;-)

go for it DV, give us your best vote. We want to know what inquiring sith lords think.

And you shall continue to want. You won't know my plan until it's far too late

I should vote Suicane75 for voting in a sixth candidate when we already had five.

Wrap your head around that one!

Thinking about this, we might have some trouble figuring out exactly which game we're in. I'll break down the problems for each game:

Game 1: seer and/or BG reveal only narrows it down to #1 and #4; WW seer has no incentive to reveal
Game 2: only the hunter can reveal; if he does, we'll likely wonder whether there are other roles (from #4) that will reveal, so we might not come to a consensus to conclude we're in #2. Also, a reveal from the hunter seems to make things tough for the village, as the hunter is its only roled player.
Game 3: the only person who could reveal is the cultist; given the precarious situation s/he is in, why would s/he reveal?
Game 4: the easiest one to determine we're in, but it would require both the hunter and either the seer or BG to reveal; that's 2 big roles to give away.

Imma gonna vote CF, because he's too good at following the rules.

VOTE CRIMSON FOX

Legal Note:

This is a Day One vote. By definition, it is a vote with little to no interpretive value with respect to the actual lupishness of said candidate. This is not to be construed, however, as a confirmation that said candidate is indeed innocent, unless he actually is. Any use of said vote against said candidate as a future basis for starting a lynch vote against said candidate or against said voter is strictly prohibited.

Unless he is a wolf, then this vote means everything, and I knew it all along.

CF

Oops. Was supposed to be, CF and I get to practice our gallows humor, but abbreviated due to the thumb slip.

or jello humor

Sorry for being out most of today. I have a class that runs from january 7-11 and i have to have read 8 books by then and be prepared to discuss them in depth and be quizzed on them. I read the first of them today, CS Lewis's Miracles. I will be reading several more this week.

Alright, now tht I'm back for the nght, let's look a twhere I should go with my vote

Vote Chief Rum


he wants vote alignment, and he's vet enough not to get surprised by Day One votes his way. It's like a meta-vote

What do you mean about vote alignment? I didn't see him say that.

1 Abe - JAG (48)
1 britrock - spleen (87)
2 CF - britrock (49), Chief Rum (110)
1 CR - Abe (117)
2 JAG - booradley (77), DT (94)
2 spleen - Suicane (97), CrimsonFox (114)

yet to vote: mauboy, Simbo, GE, DV

Well that was a pretty failed experiment at Christmas shopping today...LOL

UNVOTE britrock88
VOTE CrimsonFox

You don't get to change your vote to me without explanation. Yes, I am voting strictly to break the tie that I am in.

He said he considered voting the guy who placeda vote on a sixth dude.

Boo the villager here. Wait, that doesn't sound quite right. OK - I am a villager and I am checking in. Does everyone like my new scent?

That was kind of a weird move by CF, but that is pretty typical for his style of play.

I am a big fan of making ties on day 1 so we can see which way the voting goes. So therefore:

VOTE JAG

1 Abe - JAG (48)
3 CF - britrock (49), Chief Rum (110), spleen (121)
1 CR - Abe (117)
3 JAG - booradley (77), DT (94), GE (124)
2 spleen - Suicane (97), CrimsonFox (114)

yet to vote: mauboy, Simbo, DV

Love this! :)

(lupidity? lupousness? lupessence?)

Luposity!

Just got back, catching up and looking for any questions.

WHO ARE THE WOLVES!?!?!?

there's a question for ya

Still a few stragglers, but looks like I will be a person of interest in this lynch. There hasn't been much chatter so there isn't a lot to look at, but DT has pinged me a bit, mostly just the below post:


That struck me as possibly being an under-the-radar way to signal wolves he was the cultist and was ready to move to another candidate if a wolf was in danger. As a wolf he wouldn't need to be out there with his schedule since he could tell them in a PM. So that could be an indication there was a wolf on the block when it was 1-1-1-1-1, which isn't overly helpful since statistically there would be a decent chance of that with any random 5 players too, but it could be a starting point.

And that's my crazy day 1 theory for this game. :)

I guess I'll move to break a D1 tie bout 25 minutes left. Eitehr JAG or CF. Or I could move up spleen to make it 3-3-3/ I'da rather push someone in front though. And he's voting for me.... :)



unvote CR
Vote JAG

Quiet deadline...?

with 3 no votes.

Abe Sargent (1) - JAG (48)
CrimsonFox (3) - Britrock (49), Chief Rum (110), Spleen1015 (121)
JAG (4) - Booradley (77), Daddytorgo (94), GoldenEagle (124), Abe Sargent (132)
spleen1015 (2) - Suicane75 (97), CrimsonFox (114)

DV, mauboy, and... Simbo.

6, 2, and 3 posts...

DV's checked in today, rather early. Mau missed D1 of the last game, too. Simbo...?

Getting intense now with 20 minutes to go. Where are our non-voters?

Autumn, we're not looking at a deadline multiverse, are we? ;)

I wish we could switch our votes to one of these people who have not showed up, but I am not sure if there are enough people around to do that.

Wait for next game ... ;-)

I don't like doing that Day 1. Day two, start pushing, but life interferes with all of us.

Pros of voting for me:

1. You will not lose a roled player.
2. You will get an immediate speculation thread created in the offsite forum.

Cons of voting for me:

1. You will have voted off a villager (though the wolves can put this in the pro section)

Oooh a tie

Not much choice for me, unless someone switches off. I don't really feel strongly one way or another about CF or spleen.

Of course if CF could have been here now, he would've voted for me.

Do we know what the tie rules are? I am guessing based on the ruleset some fucked up shit is going to happen.

Weren't you the one who liked ties?

A tie is either a no-lynch or double lynch.

I'm keeping my vote on CF. Nothing against him, but JAG being around at deadline is nice.