Ok, day 1 updated

Study = Chief Rum, Danny, Narcizo, Tyketime (Tyke, CR and Danny voted Danny, Narc no vote)
Woods = Mckerney, Bhlloy, J23 (split vote among the three)
Road = Ntn, Autumn, Mr. Bug, Zinto, Jackal (not sure about votes)

Not accounted for Darth, Hoops, Commo, Dubb, and DZilla

Replace Hoops (who appaently is not in the game) with Mauboy

Crimson, can the wolves be weapon and spell experts as well?

I think we should discuss vote consolidation here, if just to increase our survival chances. This is a funny game because obviously nobody has much insight at this point and there could be a solid voting block against any of us in another thread that we're not aware of.

I'm not sold on mckerney obviously. He's just the other guy in my starting room that didn't follow J23 and I in here. So if you have any solid theories or leads (or even not solid) let's hear them.

I am voting Tyke because his vote reasoning for me was a huge stretch. It was day 1, so it doesn't necessarily mean anything, but about as much as I have to go on. I am surprised Chief voted me right after tyke as well, but I don't see him getting any other votes, so didnt go there.

its deadline now anyway

Sorry I was away earlier and missed deadline. Being sick sucks. I was in the Yard, not the woods day1 along w/ mckerney and bhlloy if that's what you were trying to pin down earlier. We had an option to go down a trail into the woods, so I'm thinking they're different places.

Looks like ntn was a villager. I assume that he was the leading vote getter between all the threads.

Yeah, I guess that means that no lynch won day 1 since we didn't see a write-up like that one?

I think there simply wasn't a lynch day one. I think there is a reasonable chance I had the most votes with 3, so the voting may have been for something else other than getting killed.

hrm, could be. Maybe it had something to do with why you ended up in the cabin rather than where you had chosen to investigate.

I'm here now, I guess. I came from the Yard where it was me, commo and dzilla. Before that I was at the trail.

Hi all... good to see more faces. I think we should be able to consolidate some information and get organized against Team Evil. I just came in from the Study, along with Narcizo and Chief Rum.

I think there could have been a lynch day 1, but we had to be in the area to see the results.

As for the day one for: Darth, Mau, Dubb, DZilla and myself we all started on the trail. Dubb went to investigate the woods then the rest of us were set to go investigate the yard, when at the last minute, without a reason DV went to the woods. We later heard a screaming noise from the woods, but couldn't tell what it was from.

For voting I can't remember specifics, but I believe it was Dubb voting Mau and one other either DV or DZ and three of us, myself included voting no lynch until we found out how the lynching worked.

As for Day two, the three of us (Mau, DZ, and myself) all came from the yard and voted for DV. Myself because of the late switch and the later screaming, Mau to consolidate the vote, and I believe DZ was random.

Not so sure about the huge stretch. It was Day 1 and we had to vote someone in the room with us. Narcizo and I had a conversation earlier that I felt comfortable with, so it was down to either you or Chief. You had only posted once and Chief posted twice. So I voted you. Nothing more. Nothing less.

You should know that both Narcizo and I have our own suspicions regarding Chief's play so far. You (Danny) are not the only one surprised that Chief quickly voted you as well...

Our vote was split across three candidates on Day 2, but one of us did vote for the eventual victim (ntndeacon). That voter was... Chief Rum!

To be fair, you didn't have to vote for anyone, that said I don't know what your reasoning was.

You can read back in this thread for the summary of what happened in the yard where I started and then obviously what happened in this room where Danny and I both stayed today.

You're right. I don't recall any of us discussing a "no lynch" scenario. We did all feel comfortable that the first vote (restricted by room) would not result in multiple lynchings.

Narcizo casts the first vote for someone not in the room. I don't think he was on the thread later when the clarification came out that we were restricted to voting someone in the room (if we wanted to cast a vote). So I did vote Danny (for the reasoning I stated above). Chief quickly placed a second vote on Danny, and then Danny voted himself.

So who did everyone vote for day 2? We had 3 votes, out of 3, for DV from the yard. Which means if ntn was lynched there needed to be at least four votes from somewhere and no one in this room voted him.

Ok, so right now there is dzilla, mauboy, Commo_Soldier, Narcizo, tyketime, Chief Rum, J23 and Danny in the main cabin.

I would like to complete my info from day one, and then start on day two.

Everyone please post who you have been with in what room for day 1 and 2 and what happened with your votes.

Good post, and enough for me to not be voting you for now. I do want to look closer at Chief though.

What is known so far.

Day 1

Study = Chief Rum, Danny, Narcizo, Tyketime (Tyke, CR and Danny voted Danny, Narc no vote)
Woods = Mckerney, Bhlloy, J23 (split vote among the three)
Road = Ntn, Autumn, Mr. Bug, Zinto, Jackal (not sure about votes)
Trail = Commo, Mauboy, Darth, Dubb and Dzilla (three no lynches, Dubb voting Mau)

Day 2
Main Cabin = Danny, J23, Bhlloy, ntndeacon (bh voted mckerney, Danny voted Tyketime, no votes from ntn or j23)
Yard = Dzilla, Mauboy, Commo (all voted DV)
Study = Chief, Narcizo, Tyketime (chief voted ntn)
Woods = Dubb, Darth, Autumn

unaccounted for = Mckerney, Mr.Bug, Jackal, Zinto

FWIW, I lean toward J23 being a villager right now.

Ha! Figured NTN would get the vote on day two.

I think we're pretty much covered what happened in the Study. I voted Chief yesterday because I got a strange vibe off of him. He forgot to investigate the study so he sat listening to the tape while tyke and I searched the room. I realised the chief vote wouldn't result in anything but I was starting to get uncomfortable with the obvious NTN/DV angle of voting UTR guys.

When I left tyke was voting Dubb. Don't know if he moved his vote later - he said he would.

Sorry he said he would consider it.

Think day one should say Yard rather than Woods Danny. I think the Woods option only popped up after the first day.

So this makes it 8 in this thread; Danny, J23, Dzilla, mauboy, Commo, Tyke, Chief and myself by my reckoning. We know NTN is dead and that Bhlloy is in the study partying by himself so that leaves 7 people outside (whether dead or live).

DV, Autumn, Zinto, Mr Bug, mckerney, Dubb, Jackal.

Ok fixed.

Day 1

Study = Chief Rum, Danny, Narcizo, Tyketime (Tyke, CR and Danny voted Danny, Narc no vote)
Yard = Mckerney, Bhlloy, J23 (split vote among the three)
Road = Ntn, Autumn, Mr. Bug, Zinto, Jackal (not sure about votes)
Trail = Commo, Mauboy, Darth, Dubb and Dzilla (three no lynches, Dubb voting Mau)

Day 2
Main Cabin = Danny, J23, Bhlloy, ntndeacon (bh voted mckerney, Danny voted Tyketime, no votes from ntn or j23)
Yard = Dzilla, Mauboy, Commo (all voted DV)
Study = Chief, Narcizo, Tyketime (chief voted ntn)
Woods = Dubb, Darth, Autumn

unaccounted for = Mckerney, Mr.Bug, Jackal, Zinto

Actually J23 did say Woods so I guess I was wrong. Must have been the trail that popped up.

:D I retracted too late. :p

We need to balance exploring with the need for there to be a lot of people in one thread so that we can create some sort of meaningful discussion and records. I'm thinking about everyone in the main cabin exploring the cellar or the yard next time around. The advantage with the cellar is that it hasn't been explored yet. The disadvantage is that it is probably a dead-end so we'll have to come back here next turn to get anywhere. Some of us have already explored the Yard but I guess the Yard leads to the Trail or the Woods. (the Road is closed - presumably a tree has fallen and blocked it off or something). The Study is the worst of both worlds as it's already been explored and it's a dead-end.

We might want to think about creating some sort of map as well. Difficult in plain text. Anyone who's been in the Yard, Trail or Woods can build on this.

Study -> Main Cabin
Main Cabin -> Cellar, Study, Yard
Yard -> Main Cabin
Cellar -> Main Cabin
Trail ->
Woods ->

With a decent number in here, we should actually be able to work up a decent vote hopeully. So far, we've been to fragmented for it to mean anything.

Bah, unfixed which is actually fixed.

k fixed.

Day 1

Study = Chief Rum, Danny, Narcizo, Tyketime (Tyke, CR and Danny voted Danny, Narc no vote)
Woods = Mckerney, Bhlloy, J23 (split vote among the three)
Road = Ntn, Autumn, Mr. Bug, Zinto, Jackal (not sure about votes)
Trail = Commo, Mauboy, Darth, Dubb and Dzilla (three no lynches, Dubb voting Mau)

Day 2
Main Cabin = Danny, J23, Bhlloy, ntndeacon (bh voted mckerney, Danny voted Tyketime, no votes from ntn or j23)
Yard = Dzilla, Mauboy, Commo (all voted DV)
Study = Chief, Narcizo, Tyketime (chief voted ntn)
Woods = Dubb, Darth, Autumn

unaccounted for = Mckerney, Mr.Bug, Jackal, Zinto

I am not sure there is a need for me to explore much anymore. I now have a weapon (the knife that was used to kill ntn) and feel fine about my ability to protect myself now. What exactly are the advantages of exploring besides getting items?

I don't know what to make of Chief. His quick Danny vote was a bit odd, but then again he was going off to work. He also seemed very quick to back off of the positions he'd been taking before and he forgot to investigate the room. The text that he was listening to the tape struck me as creepy but I guess it was colour saying that he hadn't given any instructions. Other than that I've got nothing to go off of apart from what's been reported about DV - and the question of who voted NTN and if that was a concerted effort by the wolves to save DV - if they even knew he was at risk.

We don't know basically. One advantage is that as we move to each thread then we get to see what's been happening there. Maybe if a seer has posted that he has found a baddy in the Woods thread and then dies the information dies with him unless another villager goes there.

Actually I think I can have a decent stab at this myself just based on the movement of people from day one to day two.

Study -> Main Cabin
Main Cabin -> Cellar, Study, Yard
Yard -> Main Cabin, Trail
Cellar -> Main Cabin
Trail -> Yard, Woods
Woods -> Trail

Seems likely.

I also think I have a spell, though I don't know for certain since I am a weapons expert. I'd like to pass it to someone today.

Seems logical to me.

Voting makes it look like there must have been three votes for NTN among those not accounted for on day two. I expect there's some people out in the yard this turn. We might want to stay put in the main cabin for another turn or two to let everyone congregate here, rather than dashing off and missing them.

I plan to stay here for sure.

I'm not a big fan, but I've seen enough horror movies to know the ones who go off searching die first :D

I pushed the idea of voting DV, NTN or Bug yesterday. There was a bit of discussion about how sucky it was to vote guys based on their past form which I went along with and left my vote on Chief. (first put while I thought we could only vote someone in the thread). Tyke came up with the choice of dubb or bhlloy and voted Dubb. And then I went to bed. Chief voting ntn could be interesting as DV was another candidate in our reckoning. Then again I pretty much laid a wilful throwaway vote so I can't cast any stones on that front.

Aye, but if we all go off apart from you it's not going to be us who are alone. :)

Thing is with a scenario where NTN is being pushed as a candidate to save DV is that unless the baddies are allowed access to all threads (not inconceivable) one of the baddies must have been in the Yard and voted DV, which seems a bit of a stretch but also not inconceivable.

I think I agree with Danny - we ought to hang here for at least one more turn to let Bhlloy and anyone out in the yard catch up with us. The other option would be to go to the Yard to, hopefully, meet the people from the Woods, who are probably on the trail now and will be in the yard tomorrow.

Don't pass it to me.

I ended up leaving the vote on him. We had a decent conversation about a blind voting strategy. We weren't willing to tackle the usual UTR players without confirming their participation in this game. We weren't ready to go after the big hitters either. So... I randomly selected two names from the middle of the pack (completely my terminology with no ill intent behind it), flipped a coin, and voted Dubb. There was very little discussion later which warranted any of us moving to a voting-bloc type of strategy.

Danny - Did you find the knife in the Study or here in the Main Room? And presumably the spell in the other room?

One more thing regarding the Day 2 folks here in the Main Room - was it confirmed that all of you were the leading vote-getters from the various Day One rooms?

No, it looks like it was the top four votees from across the game with a tie-breaker on people with one vote.

Don't know where to look for a vote today. I've cooled on Chief looking suspicious but the only other real candidate I can see if Darth and we don't even know if he's alive still. I'm tempted to say that we should vote someone here so they have the chance to reveal if need be. But that brings it back to Chief.

I think for the time being I'll go with DV. Mostly for information at this stage to be honest.

Vote Darth Vilus

spell in study, knife in here from ntn's back.

I'm interested in some discussion about the best strategy with regards to locations. I think we can all agree that we want to gather as many as possible in one place. However we don't know if exploring and discovering stuff will give an advantage. I suspect most other people are in the yard and the trail. If we want to check out the cellar we tell anyone arriving in this thread to stay here while we investigate the cellar for one turn. When we come back everyone should be here. We keep the majority group together and check out the cellar. In 2 turns we have pretty much everyone left in the cellar.

Good stuff when I was sleeping, I have to head off to work, but have some thoughts that I will post in about two to three hours. I agree with DV though. Something struck me as we were thinking we should stick together and he switched at the last possible minute to head into the woods with Dubb and then a screaming noise, could have been one of them yelling/asking a question, but who knows at this point.
Vote DV

I believe this is the latest (and most accurate?) summary. The rest of the voting in Day2 Study was Tyketime voted dubb, and Narcizo voted Chief.

The first thing that jumps out at me are the missing Day 1 votes from ntn (now dead), Autumn, MrBug, Zinto, & Jackal. Unfortunately, NONE of them are here in the room with us...

Why have you cooled on any suspicion of Chief? We both had our individual suspicions, and I'm not aware of anything that has occurred here in the Main Room that would cause you to at least not pursue that angle a little further. I'm not saying he's a definite vote, but I am hoping to hear some 'splaining...

I just reread the rules again. I believe it states that a tie vote results in no lynch. So while I agree that the Day 1 mechanic may have been different, we should at least keep the option open that it was a tie vote, and therefore no known lynching.

In addition to strategy for locations, I think we should also start sharing some information about objects. There's been surprisingly little discussion overall about them (at least in the Study, and now what I've read here in the Main Room).

Okay, lot of misinformation about the Study and what I did there. I don't know why Narc and tyke wouldn't at least mention my explanations to their concerns.

Let me clarify some things.

1. The Day One vote-- My "quick" vote on Danny after tyketime voted Danny was actually five whole hours later (11:44 a.m. to 4:41 p.m. local time). Not so quick. Not many posts in between, no. But to call it a quick vote, like I was trying to get away with something voting for Danny, is just completely false and is so disingenuous it makes me wonder at the motives of the person suggesting it was quick (tyketime).

I voted for Danny because he already had a vote. I didn't see the sense in having some eventual tie where we all vote for each other. And tyketime, Narc and Danny should be able to all tell you it was I that suggested that the Day One lynchees were unlikely to die anyway, as I could not see how CF would have four lynchees (from the four areas) in one day; that would be completely game unbalancing. Basically, I voted Danny with the confidence nothing would happen to him (or at least extremely unlikely). And I was right, he's still alive.

2. My Day One Investigation-- I explained this in the Study thread, but maybe it was not read by tyke for some reason. Narc clearly read it, as he references it here in thread. I simply forgot to submit an Investigation. I was running off to my second job and forgot to check back in before deadline to submit an Investigation. That is why I just sit there listening to the tape recorder, rather than investigate the room like the others did.

I'll lie about in game stuff, but not about RL stuff. I literally forgot to submit an Investigation on Day One.

3. Day two votes/Voting for normal UTR candidates-- I wasn't the one who suggested this line of voting from the start. Narc and tyke were already discussing this before I commented on anything vote-wise, and I think even before I checked in yesterday (I am on the West Coast, so since they are from Sweden and Jersey, much discussion has been happening before I even get up).

I said I did not like to vote blindly for candidates not in the room and with unknown accomplishments within the game, but I also didn't see an alternative. I said I was fine voting for an UTR candidate if that's what it came to, and I said that before tyketime came along with anything about dubb or whoever else he picked. I didn't actually vote until later in the day. I wasn't going to vote dubb because he is a good WW player and I did not want to eliminate him from the game until I knew he was a baddie.

Voting ntn "for reasons stated" was the UTR argument. I said I didn't like to vote on someone blindly--but I didn't see much choice as I was looking to vote for Narc or tyke, and I had no info on anyone else. So I was stuck relying on past play, and UTR was the primary theory we had discussed (we also discussed offing players who were historically better wolves than villagers).

4. Narc says I am too compliant?---- This happened in the Study thread. Narc suspected me because I was "too compliant". I'm not sure why this would surprise him, given much discussion happens before I even get up (that happened both days), and we didn't have any new information really. So not sure why he would expect me to rock the boat. I had no basis to go off the reservation about anything--both tyke and Narc seemed completely reasonable in their discussions to that point.

I am open to discuss whatever, any questions people may hvae. I have just been trying to figure things out like the rest of way, only with less time and usually starting hours after everyone else has begun because of where I live.

In #3, where I state "looking to vote Narc or tyke", I meant NOT "looking to vote Narc or tyke". i.e. I was not considering them as vote candidates yesterday, which forced me to consider past play in making my Day Two vote selection (which ended up on ntn from the UTR theory).

I presume you will not want to pass it to me (with the suspicions being thrown around), but I am a spells expert.

No, that is a mischaracterization of our discussion. We all agreed it was a crappy way to have to vote. I never stated I was unwilling to vote on past game play, just that I didn't like it. I in fact stated I was ready to vote on the basis of past game play, if that was the evidence left to me to go off of for my vote.

Fair enough Chief. It does look like I was the first to characterize it as "quick". Since I don't have access to the Study cabin, I didn't remember the exact time, only that it was only a few posts later. I based it partly on this recollection from Danny (while we were still in the Study):


Based on your very specific timestamps, I do apologize for the poor choice of word...

Ask what questions you want, if you want me to do any explaining. I don't know that there's anything I haven't already addressed, though. If you forgot anything I posted in the Study thread, I'll be glad to restate what I said there.

Don't sweat it, tyke. It happens. FTR, I have been going back to The Study thread to confirm this stuff and only reading what happened while I was in that room. Whatever is being done there now, I have not read past the point at which we left the Study. I don't know if that's kosher with CF or not, but I hope it is.

For me - this has been the most frustrating part of the game so far. It's tough enough with us spread out in multiple rooms. The problem is only magnified when those of us in the same room are in significantly different time zones. There have been far too many soliliquies and very few opportunities for actual interaction.

:lol: OK. I'm sure CF will weigh in, but it was my understanding that we were ONLY allowed in the thread of the room we were currently in. The fact that you had exact times led me to think you may have some special ability to read multiple threads.

I agree, it has been frustrating for me, too. I think in a bigger group like this one it's okay, which is why general WW games where we're all in discussion together, it works. But when we're split off from each other, the time zones really stand out.

I would say our particular group in the Study (Narc-Sweden, you-Jersey, Danny and I-Los Angeles) are about as messed up with the time zones as could have happened with the current WW group. Not much we can do about it but deal with it.

FWIW, I think you and Narc have done really well setting the groundwork before I or Danny got into the thread in the Study area (which is why I didn't really have much to offer most times).

You may be right. Hope I wasn't violating a game rule there. :(

I would think it would make sense that I could look back on the parts of the Study where I was in attendance, but I understand the possibility for abuse with that, since new stuff we can't know about could be happening there now with occupants there.

Actually you've answered my main concern on why you left your vote on ntn instead of considering someone else, or going with a vote-bloc. So I'm cool...

I'll be heading out soon to join Mrs Tyke on a day trip into Philadelphia and an early dinner. I hope to be back early evening. I also hope we will have more discussion by then.

I am a spells expert.

I won't have much time to post this afternoon and I may be out tonight but hopefully I can discuss a few things early this evening. I think staying here is a good idea to try to get the group together.

Investigate Cabin

Thanks for reminding me, dzilla. I have been discussing Chief Rum-centric issues so far, and ignoring the rest.

I, too, am behind the general idea that we should try to stay together. If we do need to go exploring, I recommend we send at least groups of three to do it. I would think that would minimize the risk that we would be sending a wolf-controlled team to explore.

I'm like House. My first three theories are always wrong.

Slightly less flippantly it strikes me as being as day one mania writ large due to the lack of information (as I hinted at the time).

lol

Day 1 I was in the yard, not the woods. I guess I typed the wrong thing when I was thinking about where mckerney went while typing where we started.

So the day1 summary that has bhlooy, mckerney and I in the yard to start day1 is correct. Sorry for the confusion.

Although, over-protective much Chief?

I'm still pretty interested in checking out the cellar. But I don't want to go by myself. If everyone wants to hang here then I'll go along with that.

I think we need to find another candidate than DV. The lord only knows who that might be.

Sorry, I felt there was some misinformation going there, and you and tyke were establishing doubt in me before a large group of players. I'm not going to just let that out there without challenging it.

Hey, you wanted me to be less compliant, right? :D

Neters around

INVESTIGATE CABIN

Don't want to go off down the cellar on my own and no-one else seems up for it.

I'll go with you to the cellar if you like. But we should go as at least a team of three. And then come right back after investigating.

I believe it would be good to send some to the cellar than when they come back I think it would be best if we started to explore and see what has happened else where as that can hopefully give us insight.
Investigate Cabin

I'd go to the cellar if people want, but wouldn't we have to take an extra day to investigate the cellar as well for a 2 day turnaround? I don't think it's worth our time to go there and come straight back w/o exploring.

Sorry, I meant we would explore the cellar and come back. So if that takes three days, fine. Just noting we wouldn't dilly dally there. We would want to get back to the main group as soon as we could.

In fact, I'll go ahead and throw it out there. I would ask for two volunteers to join me. If two others don't elect to go to the cellar with me by an hour to deadline, I'll switch to investigating the cabin, so as not to leave the group as a whole.

INVESTIGATE CELLAR

I guess it wasn't nearly as quick as it seemed to us due to the lack of posts. In fairness to me, I think I didn't check in that day until a little before chief made his vote, so to me Chief's vote came shortly after I saw your vote for me.

Are we allowed to save the pages before we get a new thread, or is it just notes?