You reveal this 15 minutes before the deadline? So we have one person claiming he is the seer and the other claiming to be the body guard.

In post 680 you said, "I am just a villager".

That would have been a good time to reveal.

Why do you think Poli choose you?

1. where is this hint?

2. I don't buy a bodyguard reveal this late.


3. I don't think Poli would pick you as the BG, I think he would go with someone much more low profile

We can't count on the tie at all because of the masons. The masons would have to agree with you and be already one on each, or else switch to make that happen. I don't think we can force a tie this game.

You could have been more convincing to me by not throwing so many baseless accusations around. As it is, like I said earlier, if I had to guess, I'd say you're probably telling the truth, but also, I'd say you're the more likely one to be lying of you and DT.

I don't think tie = no lynch.. it goes to the masons

Let's not forget that Poli hasn't played much so it's not outragous to think he'd pick people who he knows. Though I'm also quite skeptical of DT being anointed the BG.

I'm not saying we can count on it -- I just think it's our best option.

I tend to agree, but we are assuming the mason's would not break the tie.

I still haven't caught on to how people hint at their role. When PurdueBrad tried to pull up his old posts where he said "see" a lot it seemed like such crap and it indeed ended up being crap.

I thik you are taking the concept of draft strategy way 2 far.

And you could throw me much furter then DT, I have to be a good 30 lbs less then him :D

Not really -- in that case PB really *was* setting up a fake reveal.

please show me where I threw baseless accusations around?

Lathum your problem is that even if you're telling the truth it still might be good to have you out of the way.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 14 (14 members and 0 guests)
Passacaglia, Alan T, Barkeep49, DaddyTorgo, Danny, GoldenEagle, KWhit, Lathum, mccollins, PackerFanatic, Poli, saldana, st.cronin, Telle

Yeah I don't think Lathum has been wildly flinging stuff around at all. He just got stuck being him.

I'll show you the post numbers after deadline, but where you accused DT of setting himself up for a seer reveal, and where you accused KWhit of slight backtracking, when all he was doing was clarifying.

the hint was when i told olie i'd always love her --- aka kevin costner aka bodyguard!

i really didn't want to reveal, because now the wolves have at worst a 50/50 shot of picking me off any given night based on if i guard myself or someone else

umm.

unless I'm the seer

I hope not, because that would be a big opportunity missed by the person drafting. It doesn't seem like a big stretch to me.

I'm not sure that Whitney Houston references go over the best on a sports message board :p

Right but there's only 50/50 of that. That's what sucks for you.

Add clap to that list.

Yeah talk about a weak hint.

and I am a the seer and those 2 are on me hot and heavy so I hardly think my accusations are baseless.


come to think of it, the only way YOU would know they were baseless is if you had insight into who is/isn't a wolf.

These kind of obscure 'hints' don't really hit home when the posts are coming once every ten seconds or so.

I saw the hint, didnt connect it to the reveal, but man that awful song got stuck in my head :(

So if it were a stronger hint, you guys would be more inclined to believe him? I don't get the concept of hinting that you have a role at all. Maybe that's why I wasn't chosen for one.

nice...pick on the fatty of the group. imma sit on you next time i see you!!:rant:

What kind of *?#$ is that?

u outing yoursefl as a wolf?

Oh yeah, there was also the time you came after Passacaglia, when all he did was point out the holes in your arguments.

not buying that reveal at all from DT....what are the odds out of 21 players that the 2 we pick to be our lynch candidates both have roles.

gee, I'm sure I have some reason for it!

I agree that hints are over rated except if you're the seer and are trying to hint at who you've scanned in case you die.

I assume Alan is worried about a non-cunning wolf.

...you're allowed to vote for yourself?

I'm sure you must too. It's still crap.

WTF?

See! Now look at what you've done Alan. Sheesh I'm playing in another game and the person self voted there too. It's like the WW gods are trying to rub my least favorite player action in my face.

Eh. He doesn't even have to vote at all. But now we know if Alan dies, it's likely that the killer was....Alan! :eek:

It's past deadline. i won't spoil St.Cronin's writeup for him.. but I play a part in the end result.. and thus you will find out my role.

I'll comment more after night actions are over. Either I'll be night killed by wolves (thus my role fully listed), or I'll explain my thoughts about today and go into full detail on my role at that point.

also, if DT is the bodyguard, no way he should have been out and point fingers...he should have gone quiet and let other people stand out....to be any help, the BG has to stay just as hidden as the seer.

Deadline

Word.

Damn you guys post too fast.

I agree fully.. I hate self votes. In this situation it felt like the best strategy though for myself. I obviously didn't do it in the normal self-vote fashion.