Me, a GM and a clock: My Life in Werewolf by path

I always assumed that was part of the risk for this game.

Ok, here's the problem. CR seems like a very viable candidate to me, but he probably won't be around to defend himself before the lynch would happen, right? So, I'm hesitant.

NTN, NFG both seem like reasonable choices in lieu of a CR vote, but what do other people think?

I noticed Telle was near the bottom if not at the bottom of posts. I know she doesn't always post a lot but I think I can recall another game where she was very quiet and turned up bad. So I have no problem with that probing vote path made.

I know a lot of people will disagree with me about it, but I try not to concern myself with everyone else's schedule and just play it as if everyone was here all the time. That way I don't have to get all bent out of shape if someone lies about their real-life schedule. I know everyone claims doing that is so horrible they would never do it, but I figure if I put myself in a position where it just doesn't matter to me, it's not even an issue.

Anyway, does anyone have an updated vote count?

Alright well just to encourage some more activity perhaps:

vote CR

+1

Nah, it's gotta be more than that.

As of 1511

Autumn: nfg (1132 9:42 pm)
Telle: path (1502, 4:49 pm)
nfg: PB (1417, 2:33 PM) King (1418, 2:34 PM)
Jackal: Thomakl (1411, 2:24 PM) Pass (1425 2:57 pm) iSidiqui (1465 3:52 pm)
Danny: Autumn (1450, 3:21 PM)
Chief Rum: Telle (1428 2:58 pm) Jackal (1511 5:50 pm)

i was actually willing to vote jackal again today until he defended me earlier in the day...he could easily have seized upon the accusations that DT was inferring and tried to get a push going on me...to not do that was extremely unwolflike.

telle on the other hand made a move that jumped off the page at me, so i am completely comfortable with this...also, i was a wolf with her in the fake role reveal game, and she is possibly the best person at hiding UTR that i have ever seen.

vote telle

How many people have not voted yet?

8 by my count.

Danny, Schmidty, Chief Rum, BrianD, ntndeacon, saldana, henry296, EagleFan

Well, sal just voted.

Well, ISidd said he wasn't going to be back, and I'm not sure about Thomkal. You're set on voting for me, Pass?

Whoops. I was just going off BK's vote count and comparing it to the first page (which still has Alan T listed as alive, btw).

No. When I voted NFG had 5, and you had 1. As I said then, DT's comments were enough to make me want to keep it close, but not be all gung-ho for lynching you or anything.

So it's Danny, Schmidty, Chief Rum, ntndeacon, and henry296, and I dunno if we are to expect votes from BrianD and EagleFan or what.

Well, there's a bunch of candidates now, even if you are disregarding NFG because of DT, do you think I'm the best choice out of all those people?

I honestly have no idea. But I'm definitely willing to see what happens as I check in throughout the evening.

I'm feeling much better. I think I'll go for a walk.

As the night goes on I may have to move off CR simply for self-defense sake, but it really depends on if people show up and vote.

You were already dead when he made that remark. The list was correct. We can't help it if he can't read. Anyhow your mother was a hamster and your father smells of elderberry.

Whoops, I must not have refreshed my Page 1 tab at home since early this morning. Sorry Alan!

Wow. Lots to catch up up!!!!!!!!!

or just unavailable for large periods of time.

FYI guys, we just hit the 23:00 mark at 6:54 Central.

I think probably the more telling bit of info about me was the double run on me in day one. I find it hard to believe that hapens for a wolf.

That is not correct. The clock restarts when the lynch results are posted which was 8:04 yesterday.

I'll really not getting thing as far as anywhere to start.

Okay, this is tough, because my gut says nfg is the most likely candidate from Danny's list to be a wolf. That's purely on gut, though, and what DT had to say carries weight.

The problem for me is that once again I am a candidate, and I am not sure I have much of a choice in where to put my vote. I would probably stick with nfg with no other considerations, but I think I will have to go with The Jackal out of self-defense.

I don't have a big problem voting The Jackal, though either-- he's right behind nfg, along with some of the others Danny pointed out with his excellent analysis.

I have to believe by now I will have been scanned, and that person told DT. I hope I will be cleared soon.

VOTE THE JACKAL

Well, that pretty much ties my hands, unless more people will realize that based on voting records CR is a much better candidate than me.. really, most of the people up there are better candidates than me.

I'm tired of Danny's "excellent analysis" being used as an argument against me. We've already established my votes are still unknown, and "possibly" suspicious, but certainly not as suspicious as others - and Danny admitted he voted for me because of he felt about my response to him.

So right now, with multiple votes, it is Jackal, Telle, CR, and nfg. I am considering moving, going back through to see where I should move if I do.

See, this is what happens, Danny. I talk about some candidates and no one does anything. And people wonder why I'm frustrated.

Jackal, if you weren't limited by self-defense and not affected by who has voted for you, who would you have voted for today?

FYI guys, we just hit the 23:00 mark at 7:04 Central.

I don't think I'm even going to use my power. Have fun screwing yourselves over.

NM, I'll look back, maybe I missed the very answer to my question.

I'm already voting for CR..

I think that telle, NFG, and NTN are good choices as well.

Well, I'll try to make this a bit more interesting and hopefully generate some movement.

unvote nfg

vote Chief Rum

I actually have been a little concerned about several of the under the radar folks as well. (yes I know pot calling the kettle here) But I do want some pressure brought to bear with that group as a whole. I have certainly wondered about her loyalty. Therefore...
Vote Telle

Glad you did that ntn, I was split on which person to go to. I wouldn't mind seeing this kept close so we have some analysis of votes/unvotes to go from.

yea but the bad thing is we need what 7 or 8 to get a lynch?

Well, at 24:00 that number goes down (and right now it's 8, I think).

Doesn't that number drop over the next hour or so?

In order, I'm torn between Telle-CR (and probably prefer Telle but the last two games I've played with her she's been a wolf and that is probably coloring that some) and then Jackal, so he's the #3 choice for me right now.

Hit enter too soon, continued from above: So my vote is on CR due to the odd KWhit vote and that I think past games are coloring my view of Telle's play.

I was actually struggling between the two of them as well. I think part of the problem we have so many potential wolves those that are suspicious split us contrary to the common view held by the wolves...(I am assuming they can talk normally)

Just curious, why am I your third choice?

Jackal, I also think these are good choices. I'm not sure on you or anything, but if I had my druthers, I would rather go wit hone of them. My vote needs to be on you for self defense, though. I don't have any way of proving to you I am not a member of the Conspriacy (but then that goes for yuo as well).

My voting record is hardly something you can cconclude anything from at this point. My Day One vote was a vote I openly admitted I had nothign for because I lacked the time to read up on the thread that day, and only voted for KWhit to get a third candidate involved. I had no idea DT would also throw his weight behind that vote.

My other two votes are both self-defense.

I feel like NFG is a good choice, I don't have as good a feeling about him being a wolf that I do on you, but they are just feelings, so if we can be agreed on moving to him (or Telle, who I feel is a better target), I can move off of you for now, maybe give some people the chance to scan one or both of us.

telle is an "ok" choice - she is MT right now, I will say that. jackal is making me more suspicious with the "i'll just give up" thing - that's such a wolfish type of play.

jackal - if you do die I will explain to you in PM.

I have said all along - the NI's are fair game though. that's jackal, ntn, chief rum, eaglefan, thomkal, and a couple others that I am forgetting cuz my list is in the car. hopefully leaving the cape here in a few minutes. intendto vote when I get home.

mapquest bourne ma to wellesley ma if you want to figure how long that will be.

sorry if we lynch a good-guy ni but sometimes you gotta take one for the team

If DT says Telle is okay, I'll make that move. I'm out for a while, hope this helps.

unvote CR
vote Telle

Actually I prefer Telle, too. I always get a little buggy about her, I admit, because in just about every game we play together, she comes to the conclusion I am wolf (regardless of the truth) and screams it to high heavens. Every now and then is okay, but every game, it gets a little tiring.

And besides she pings me a lot as a wolf, and that was even before Danny's analysis. Plus, unlike nfg, she doesn't have a hint of support from DT, I don't believe. So I can switch to Telle.

In fact, I will, and I hope you will follow suit. And, yes, hopefully, a scan is coming in the near future (although I would be pretty surprised if I haven't beens canned already).

UNVOTE THE JACKAL
VOTE TELLE

I'm in class, vote count?

Also, Jackal, this is werewolf, people vote for you, it happens. Your take the ball and go home attitude doesn't help us.

Posting as I go along, but I had the same conclusion as Pass as Alan knew we had an extra vote and basically said I can't tell you why.

I'm surprised that I'm not under more suspiciouv.

No but it's not hurting anyone. And it makes me feel a little better.

And Jackal I dont have the vote count, so don't know if you're right there for lynch votes, buy if you are, why not use your power and prove yourself if you are possibly going down.

I think Telle's in front now.

Do you want to be?

As of 1569

Autumn: nfg (1132 9:42 pm)
Telle: path (1502, 4:49 pm) saldana (1515 6:28 pm) ntn (1548 7:11 pm) CR (1561 7:30 pm) Purdue (1560, 7:30 PM) Jackal (1566 7:34)
nfg: King (1418, 2:34 PM)
Jackal: Thomakl (1411, 2:24 PM) Pass (1425 2:57 pm) iSidiqui (1465 3:52 pm)
Danny: Autumn (1450, 3:21 PM)
Chief Rum: Telle (1428 2:58 pm)

If Jackal is not a wolf, I find Thomkal's jump onto Jackal as the second candidate quite interesting. Probably too late for that. I am ok with Telle too, but the run on her has me a little worried.

I thimk my vote will tip it for Telle, any last arguments?

Just caught up...Going to go work on the voting record

my only thought and yes I am on her, is we are killing a mt before a ni.

Alright *fingers crossed*

Vote Telle

probably the right move. we needed to lynch someone.

Not sure if that matters, but I got some PM info about this

That's 7 votes of 19, right? Unless EF and BrianD don't count.

7/19 = 36.8% (FWIW, 8/19 = 42.1%)
7/17 (if EF and Brian don't count) = 41.1%

I got some PM info and am trusting someone with that vote.

well 6 now

I'd like to see some more heat on CR here

I'm noticing King, Thomkal here in the thread now. If CR is a wolf, I wouldn't be surprised if one or two others are here not doing or saying anything.

Wow, go away for a while and a lot changes. Danny, can you elaborate?

Okay, so what's the deal. Why the heat on me now?

Guys, lynch CR, if I am wrong for trusting this person, go ahead and lynch me.

ok I will bite. I still think Telle should be kept under watchful eyes. But CR is another of whom I have doubts.
Unvote Telle
Vote CR

Someone PMed me telling me he was a wolf with absolute certainty. I believe this person is telling me the truth.

Wow, a ton does change.

Danny, do you mean they did this from some ability or role (seer or something)?

It doesn't prove that I'm good, just that I'm telling the truth about my ability.

Funny how this came up Danny just as Telle was getting enough votes to be lynched.

They did not say exactly, but it is a person I tend to believe.

Okay, so how can I respond to this? Some person who won't come out in public that you're using your judgment on as being truthful, and that's how the basis under which you want to see me lynched?

I am not a wolf. No, I don't have anyway to prove it. But lynching me is a mistake. There are plenty of logical reasons to lynch the other candidates we have put up. If I am going to get lynched, I would like to know why.

And if this is true, we know of another wolf in addition to Telle. I don't think the person who PM'ed is a wolf, but if CR is not, then this person must be. If this is wrong, I will give up the person who PM'ed me.

In fact, I can probably name us two additional wolves if this person is lying.

DAY 3
(1114) DT vote Autumn – Autumn 1
(1116) PB vote Autumn – Autumn 2
(1118) Danny vote Autumn – Autumn 3
(1120) CR vote Autumn – Autumn 4
(1124) EF vote Autumn – Autumn 5
(1127) ISiddiqui vote Autumn – Autumn 6
(1132) nfg vote Autumn – Autumn 7
(1144) UNVOTE CR off Autumn – Autumn 6
(1118) UNVOTE Danny off Autumn – Autumn 5
(1157) Danny vote Autumn – Autumn 6
(1171) UNVOTE DT off Autumn – Autumn 5
(1182) Danny vote Autumn – Autumn 4
(1183) UNVOTE EF off Autumn – Autumn 3
(1237) ALAN is killed
(1347) path vote PB – Autumn 3, PB 1
(1350) Autumn vote nfg - Autumn 3, PB 1, nfg 1
(1383) UNVOTE ISiddiqui off Autumn – Autumn 2, PB 1, nfg 1
(1384) UNVOTE PB off Autumn - Autumn 1, PB 1, nfg 1
(1405) Danny vote nfg – nfg 2, Autumn 1, PB 1
(1411) Thomkal vote jackal – nfg 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, jackal 1
(1417) PB vote nfg - nfg 3, Autumn 1, PB 1, jackal 1
(1418) king vote nfg - nfg 4, Autumn 1, PB 1, jackal 1
(1419) jackal vote nfg - nfg 5, Autumn 1, PB 1, jackal 1
(1425) pass vote jackal - nfg 5, jackal 2, Autumn 1, PB 1
(1428) telle vote CR - nfg 5, jackal 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1
(1450) UNVOTE Autumn off nfg - nfg 4, jackal 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1
(1450) Autumn vote Danny - nfg 4, jackal 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1, Danny 1
(1463) UNVOTE Danny off nfg - nfg 3, jackal 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1, Danny 1
(1465) ISiddiqui vote jackal - nfg 3, jackal 3, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1, Danny 1
(1468) Danny vote jackal - jackal 4, nfg 3, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1, Danny 1
(1475) UNVOTE jackal off nfg - jackal 4, nfg 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1, Danny 1
(1475) jackal vote danny - jackal 4, nfg 2, Danny 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1
(1495) UNVOTE Danny off jackal - jackal 3, nfg 2, Danny 2, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1
(1498) UNVOTE jackal off danny - jackal 3, nfg 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, PB 1, CR 1
(1502) UNVOTE path off PB - jackal 3, nfg 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, CR 1
(1502) path vote telle - jackal 3, nfg 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, CR 1, telle 1
(1511) jackal vote CR - jackal 3, nfg 2, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, telle 1
(1515) saldana vote telle - jackal 3, nfg 2, CR 2, telle 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1
(1536) CR vote jackal - jackal 4, nfg 2, CR 2, telle 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1
(1547) UNVOTE pass off nfg - jackal 4, CR 2, telle 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1547) pass vote CR - jackal 4, CR 3, telle 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1548) ntn vote telle - jackal 4, CR 3, telle 3, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1560) UNVOTE PB off CR - jackal 4, telle 3, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1560) PB vote telle - jackal 4, telle 4, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1561) UNVOTE CR off jackal - telle 4, jackal 3, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1561) CR vote telle - telle 5, jackal 3, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1566) UNVOTE jackal off CR - telle 5, jackal 3, CR 1, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1566) jackal vote telle - telle 6, jackal 3, CR 1, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1575) danny vote telle - telle 7, jackal 3, CR 1, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1577) UNVOTE danny off telle - telle 6, jackal 3, CR 1, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1577) danny vote CR - telle 6, jackal 3, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1587) UNVOTE ntn off telle - telle 5, jackal 3, CR 2, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1
(1587) ntn vote CR - telle 5, jackal 3, CR 3, Danny 1, Autumn 1, nfg 1

We can talk about you later, CR is the topic of discussion now. :p

Some other CR things, on day two, when PB and CR both had about the same, support for CR died out and PB moved up. Today again, not much support for CR past the initial two or so.

As I was doing this recap, I couldn't help but think that the wolves may be "sacrificing" one of their own in Telle and then using the voting record the next few days as an alibi.

Not sure what to make of the latest info that just came up other than it sounds pretty good.

Guys, we are not at end game here, this person is unlikely to be lying

Then I can tell you right now that you know two additional wolves, because he is lying. Of course, this is like talking into dead silence. How can I respond when I do not know the manner in which I am being accused? If you won't share who this person is, Danny, can you at least say why you trust them so much, or if they offered anything other than "he is a wolf"?

Unvote nfg
Vote CR


I'll go with Danny on this one.

Wow.

Based on my post after Day 1 on the middle votes for Kwhit, led me to Telle today and I felt CR was ok b/c I didn't think his day 1 vote was based. I think Jackal is good and the frustration is real.

I wish someone would confirm Danny's story before I vote. However, given my statements above, I'll pick nfg22 for now but could change with more info as last nights exhcange seems a bit odd.

vote nfg22

Honestly, if this person is lying, it hurts us little. You die, but we catch wolves. If he is lying it is a very bad play.