This is interesting. Of course, it will be easy for Telle to hide behind what she learned now bhlloy has been killed.

We are down to 5, myself and the two couples. Either Telle was responsible for bhlloy's death or she was the doctor trying to heal him or she is the seer.

I don't see much that would've lead Telle to assume bhlloy was a bad guy that she would use a seer scan on him. Could she be the doctor and thought he made be a target? Perhaps, but still think it is a better than 50% chance she is bad.

Lets get some discussion going here, we're 3.5 from deadline.

Based on my knowledge from day 1 (which may or may not have any value) I'm looking at Goldeneagle and Telle. I think GE needs to be our main focus based on his day 2 remarks and vote movements.

Thoughts?

The real day one or the one after the tie when roles were changed?

The real day 1. I was part of the badguy team. Day 2 both of us were vanilla wolves.

I'm guessing Day one GE and Telle were vanila wolves and now...not so much.

I’d rather not speculate on who switched teams or not but judge based on what they did since. Until I hear from Telle I can’t reasonably determine if someone else is viable. About to exercise. Should be back after 9.

Well since henry296 outed me... I'm the doctor. I had been chosen bhlloy for healing. It didn't work out, but in the end that turned out to be a good thing.

I had noticed towards the end of Day 3 that bhlloy had seemed to be giving gentle suggestions that GoldenEagle was good. I guessed that bhlloy was likely the seer, and had scanned GoldenEagle, and based on that scan was trying to lead us away from voting for him without giving that away too obviously. So I chose bhlloy in case any of the baddies picked up on the same hints.

Since bhlloy turned out to actually be the count, my guess now is that GoldenEagle is the wolf he converted into a "killing machine".

vote GoldenEagle

Haha.. re-read my role email from EF. Healing works on a fellow werewolf, which bhlloy was not. So that's why it didn't work, duh :)

Frankly I cannot refute any of that but I'm still getting a weird vibe from Telle.

That said I was ready to vote GE last night. I'm willing to stick with that.


VOTE GOLDENEAGLE

Vote Telle

We are just going to give her a pass when she was obviously there when holly was killed. It seems prettt obvious to me that she is a villager that probably did the killing.

Well no big surprise on GoldenEagle's response. What else is he going to say?

As I told GE yesterday, I'll say again, we'll deal with him tonight, and Her tomorrow.

If what you said here is correct and we're right about GoldenEagle, then there is no tomorrow because we won! :)

And yet to vote: henry296 and LoneStarGirl

Perhaps.

Oh show some optimism. After this shitty day I need something good to happen!

I think you have that order reversed. Lynch Telle today and if she comes back clean, I will vote for myself tomorrow.

We know that henry saw her there. We know that the villagers and vampires attacked each other. This seems like the easiest slam dunk vote in the history of WW.

She can claim to be the doctor. Why did she visit bhlloy? It makes no sense. He is dead and that is good thing for us, but it came at the hand of a villager that pretty obviously seems like Telle.

Is everyone asleep?

Vote telle

I explained why I chose bhlloy for the healing action. You're just ignoring that because it ties you to him.

I knew as soon as I posted I messed up and gave her an out. I was hoping maybe we also had a seer who could help us rule out three special roles which is giving me pause. I don’t think it matters what order we do this. However we should rule out Telle first since we know she was out last night.

Vote Telle

So 3-2 telle right now?

Really, people?

Day 1 I was a vanilla villager
Day 2 I chose timmae, based on no more than gut.. just figured I should choose somebody. And then he pulled that attempted tie bullshit, so I was pissed at myself for thinking he was good as much as I was pissed about what he did. That visceral reaction of mine should be pretty clear if you reread.
Day 3 I chose bhlloy because, as I said, he was giving a Seer vibe with how he seemed to be defending Golden Eagle

Don't kill one of the few remaining good guys, and one that might actually be able to help keep the wolves alive tonight!

I'm good with either one so I'll sit here and see who is right, and who is...dead.

So that's how you're all going to vote, with GoldenEagle having nothing more going for him than, "I'm not Telle"?

He was one of the four who claimed vanilla wolf on Day 2, and was thus viewed as suspicious. He was being defended by bhlloy, who turned out to be the count.

I think an eyeball witness seeing you moving around at night when someone was actually killed is too large of a hurdle for anyone to overcome.

And that's how roled good guys get killed off ALL THE TIME. This sucks!!!

*sigh* Well, good luck wolves.

I can't really affect this now, however, rest assured (and in peace) that we'll deal with GE and apparently LSG tomorrow.

Let's not get ahead of ourselves yet.

Looks like eagle fan forgot about us

Hopefully it's not his mom again :(

Well lets say you're right and Telle is bad.

Game should be over as the wolves should be the only ones left.

IF Telle is good then the game should ALSO be over because the villagers almost certainly have an even match at 2-2 (I honestly don't believe there is only 1 baddie left if Telle turns out good.

I'm guessing the game is over either way unless something truly weird is going on.

If it doesn't end and she was GOOD, then I'm looking squarely at you GE.

does that add it all up? or have I confused everyone, including myself?

This x2

Yes, I think you are confused. But let's see how this plays out.

Sorry, got distracted by a conversation with my daughters.

Well fuck.....I know where THAT result came from....

I TOLD you GoldenEagle was the count's convert! But no, you were focused on me. (Ok, yeah I was bad too. But I was also right! :) )

I have definitely learned my lesson, to NEVER allow a tie in one of your games!

Day one was really interesting with the names that were flying around. Based on orders that stood at one point it may have been a near slam dunk win for the wolves.

Well part of that was RendeR's fault. Needs to learn to keep his big mouth shut in person. I swear I should have put, "I will not discuss werewolf outside of the game," into our wedding vows! :)

I didn't expect this to end tonight, although as it played out I think it would have been pretty easy to get Render voted out tomorrow.

I did start off as the wolf seer and was going to scan CR. It was a pure guess and I respect him a lot as a player so I just wanted to know where he was at.

I got converted by bhlloy the next night.

henry following Telle helped a lot. Without that, not sure I could have influenced the vote on her so easily.

Thanks for running the game EF and I enjoyed it. I hope we get to do it again in the near future.