Im gonna vote with my gut here. I think that ntndeacon was more suspicious then swaggs. so....

I vote ntndeacon

So deacon is definitely a villager then. ;)

Hmmmm....Is it even worth it for me to unvote KWhit and revote for ntndeacon?

swaggs: no, if we find out your a villager it wouldnt matter. It we find out your a wolf you could have been changing your vote to a wolf, just to take the heat off you. Either way, your boned!

So... I'm still waiting for everyone else to follow Airhog's lead... :)

Considering he's been wrong every time I think we ARE following his lead :)

Touche.

So, where's that steak?

I can see how you'd be hungry after not eating any of last night.

I just hope my steak doesn't taste too much like Shorty or BrianD.

Swaggs deserves to go just because he has a link to the Dean Houston Blog in his sig.

:)

Any other good reasons to lynch an innocent, werewolf?

I'm calling the voting since I don't think anyone will be changing their minds.

Swaggs - 8 (Kevin, Barkeep, eaglesfan, mustang, kwhit, jon, desnudo, ntndeacon)

kwhit - 1 (swaggs)

ntndeacon - 1 (Airhog)


Swaggs seems fairly resigned to the whole thing. Sure, he turns into a werewolf, but you don't really have any trouble dispatching him.

Night 7

Jon
Swaggs - Lynched on Day 6 (werewolf)
TazFTW - Lynched on Day 2 (villager)
Airhog - Duke
NoMyths - killed on Night 5 (Sorceror)
Qwikshot - Lynched on Day 3 (Cultist)
Barkeep49
ntndeacon
McSweeny - killed on Night 3 (Witness)
Shorty - Lynched on Day 1 (villager)
Kwhit
Mustang
BrianD - lynched on Day 4 (Doctor)
Condors - killed by the Hunter on Night 4 (Villager)
Eaglesfan
GWB - killed on Night 4 (Hunter)
KevinNU7
Desnudo
Lathum - Lynched Day 5 (Werewolf)

Please have your night actions in as soon as possible.

Doh... Busted.

Good luck to my fellow wolves.

If what I expect to happen happens ---kick ass villagers. It was fun.

The night passes quickly, and the remaining survivors in the manor wake slowly, heading to the kitchen to eat the remaining scraps of food, which is running in very short supply. The morning ritual of the room check not unexpectedly turns up the remains of Jon who has been torn to pieces. Also not surprisingly, he was the Seer.

Day 7

Jon - killed on Night 7 (seer)
Swaggs - Lynched on Day 6 (werewolf)
TazFTW - Lynched on Day 2 (villager)
Airhog - Duke
NoMyths - killed on Night 5 (Sorceror)
Qwikshot - Lynched on Day 3 (Cultist)
Barkeep49
ntndeacon
McSweeny - killed on Night 3 (Witness)
Shorty - Lynched on Day 1 (villager)
Kwhit
Mustang
BrianD - lynched on Day 4 (Doctor)
Condors - killed by the Hunter on Night 4 (Villager)
Eaglesfan
GWB - killed on Night 4 (Hunter)
KevinNU7
Desnudo
Lathum - Lynched Day 5 (Werewolf)

We're going into the weekend, so I'm going to speed the voting up, as soon as everyone votes (and doesn't seem likely to change their mind) we'll have the lynching. Maybe we can get two rounds in before Friday night. After that I'll decide, the rest of the weekend will probably be one day unless all the survivors are available.

I'm not fooled by Swaggs voting for KWhit or KWhit voting for Swaggs. The past voting pattern reveals much.

I vote KWhit.

8 survivors out of the original 19. Hope everyone has been having fun in this game (though it sucks if you're eliminated first.)

This would seem to indicate that there is at least two more out there. I've never quite been sold on the whole KWhitt as wolf. Could a supporter reiterate the reasoning there? To me Kevin has always been more suspicous, even with more limited voting.

I've been having a blast! Thanks for running this :)

Of course, he could have been intentionally misleading us. I guess we'll find out after we lynch another wolf. I've gotta run in a minute, but KWhit's voting patterns and arguments have shown a protective inclination towards Lathum when his life was in doubt. Also, there have been several other questionable votes. If no one else has done so, I'll post more of my thoughts before I go to sleep tonight.

Me, too.

Thanks Peregrine. It's been great. I'll definitely be following along when/if you do it again.

I picked up on that too... Swaggs last feeble attempt at mind games? :D

If there is anything for me, it is that whole mailbox full thing.. either his mailbox was really full at the time and a fellow wolf was sending him that or it was someone setting him up.. I never sent him a PM to see if it was really full as, in my eyes, would have been cheating. (should address that after the game... but.. anyways)

Other than that, with the Lathum vote being the big evidence right now, it is NTN, KWhit.. KWhit, NTN.. flip a coin.. We have the advantage now so..

Well since KWhit was the one who brought up the clear the mailbox thing at the start I see that as him actually setting himself up to make himself look inoccent. It was such an obvious setup that I actually think he's guilty. So I guess that would be one reason to support his lynching.

While it has been tremendously entertaining to watch all the speculation, I would hate for innocent actions to impact this game. My ping to Kwhit was purely and totally separate from this game. I hadn't even looked in this thread until after I posted that ping. I am a journalist in the IHOF and my PM to him was purely IHOF related. I needed information for an article I was writing. It will be published sometime in the next day or so. You can PM VPI for independent verification.

Sorry if my actions impacted your game, but it was purely unintentional.

Scrawls

*shakes head*

My reasons for picking KWhit have been outlined in previous posts. I agree with Eaglesfan, it's open and shut. If you go back and read posts, I think it is pretty clear. As for Kevin, I don't think a wolf would have wasted so many votes. It's certainly possible, but I think the evidence is stacked against KWhit.

Nothing that's happened since we lynched Lathum has changed my opinion. How people voted today really means nothing since everyone knew Swaggs was getting lynched.

I vote KWhit

Being eliminated 2nd was no party either.

Scrawls, whomever you are you have some baaaaad timing.

This reminds me of that one MASH episode where BJ says he could get everyone on a practical joke and Hawkeye was all paranoid.. and some innocent doctor showed up and Hawkeye went crazy on him thinking he was in on a setup..

Of course, no one probably remembers that because I think I'm the only one that ever liked MASH.. but.. anyways... I digress. :D

MASH sucked

Hey now... be nice. :D

Is that the one where Hawkeye was the only one to be gotten, because of his paranoia. and Klinger blew up his own file cabinet? I like that show. However the Movie is still better.

Well, I might as well do this tonight. I don't see it changing.
Vote for Kwhit

Wow, I actually worked about two hours over today so I could read this entire thread. I did actually get a couple of hours of work in today though, so it all evens out in the end. Much fun, much fun. I can't wait for werewolf 4!! Playing along would be even better.

And now, let the ridicuality continue...

I can't believe how long this thread is, and almost half the players are still in.

That's the real secret, the game is just a front, I'm just here for the post count. ;)

Though 1200-1400 posts seems about right for this kind of game.

Well, since there are 5-7 werewolves left, the game shouldn't last too much longer. :)

Im gonna go with my gut, and

I vote ntndeacon

I think KWhit and Deacon are both wolves. One if brutal and the other one may be Cursed. Or actually, maybe one of the two former wolves were thw cursed one.

Anyways, it hard to defend my two non-votes other then to say that I am mostly on the net only when I am at work, and on those days when I left work I did not have a good pick yet. I will not vote for someone without atleast a reason.

So today I will vote for Deacon or KWhit. I'm leaning towards Deacon since he has done little to defend himself. KWhit has atleast made attempts, even though I don't think they ahve been very convincing

If there was that many left then the game would be over

Well, I already voted, but to just let you know, I probably won't be around til 5 or 6 PM Central Time as I'm about to leave for my first day of work at the new job and I'm not sure if I'll have internet access yet (I need a security password to get on the internet.)

I've done my best to explain voting for Jon. But I'll say it again, it was not in support of Lathum, contrary to what has been suggested. If Jon had used a better argument at first (something about Lathum's voting history other than the typo argument), I might have believed him. Instead, I was convinced he was a wolf trying to save his neck or get the real seer to expose himself.

The game is still in doubt. Voting for a villager at this point could tip the balance back to the wolves.

Think this through before you cast your vote. I am an innocent villager.

And I am convinced that ntndeacon's 8:00 vote was not just a coincidence. Are we supposed to believe that he just happened to get in from a movie, log on, and vote at that precise time? Doesn't sound right to me.

I vote ntndeacon.

Ok, for now I'm going to say Deacon. I mean really, does this guy every post????

I vote for ntndeacon

Tied 3-3 with two more voters to go.

Airhog - ntndeacon
Barkeep49
ntndeacon - KWhit
Kwhit - ntndeacon
Mustang
Eaglesfan - KWhit
KevinNU7 - ntndeacon
Desnudo - KWhit

Wow, I was traveling from Texas to NJ yesterday and could't keep up with anything. The game is getting very interesting, there have been so many twists from mysterious full inboxes to last minute votes to people not voting at all. I can't wait for the outcome.

Well I don't like to change the rules in midstream, but I'm not really happy with the current tie rule. From now on the new tie rule will be, if there is a tie in the voting at the deadline (or when no one can be convinced to change their vote) then no one will be lynched that day.

As if you needed more pressure...

Oh crap, that really helps the wolves.

Well there haven't been any ties so far, and I don't expect to see any anyway. By this point though you're all so desperate and paranoid that you will have to lynch someone, this just enforces that.

Well, both have my doubts on their innocence and guilt.. I voted for him once, I'll vote again..

Vote NTNDeacon

Is there going to be an early lynching? Hopefully, NTN will be the final wolf and the game will be done.. and we can get to the rewrap.. (and bragging..) :D

I'm hoping for an early lynching but we'll need all the votes.

So I guess I'm the last one, huh? And I'm not really convinced of either person's guilt. I guess there is slightly more reason for Kwhitt than ntn, though. So I Vote for Kwhitt.

Okay you guys are tied right now, by my count, 4-4. Anyone want to change their mind?

I'm still not decided on the tie rule. Hopefully it won't come up... ;)

I will switch to NTNDeacon if no one is willing to switch to KWhit. I really think the case is much stronger for the latter, but Deacon has been suspicious enough to take a chance.

Why the hell would Barkeep vote for me to induce a tie if he's "not really convinced of either person's guilt?"

Umm... A tie helps the wolves, Barkeep.

All right, against my better judgement I vote NTNDeacon. A tie probably loses us a villager tonight and doesn't change anything except that there would not be a tie tomorrow.

I tie would lose us a villager actually.. (unless the bodyguard is correct...), I can't think of any reason to tie the vote up. ???

Ok it 5-3 let's give it until 11. FYI I'm willing to flip flip so if a tie comes up again I will move my vote. Nice try wolfies

Exactly, that's why I untied it.

Final Vote??

Okay, the final vote is:

ntndeacon - 5 (Airhog, Kwhit, KevinNU7, Desnudo, Mustang)

Kwhit - 3 (ntndeacon, eaglesfan, barkeep)


You string ntndeacon up with ruthless efficiency, despite his protests to the end. Valid protests, since he was an innocent villager!

Night 8

Jon - killed on Night 7 (seer)
Swaggs - Lynched on Day 6 (werewolf)
TazFTW - Lynched on Day 2 (villager)
NoMyths - killed on Night 5 (Sorceror)
Qwikshot - Lynched on Day 3 (Cultist)
ntndeacon - lynched on Day 7 (Villager)
McSweeny - killed on Night 3 (Witness)
Shorty - Lynched on Day 1 (villager)
BrianD - lynched on Day 4 (Doctor)
Condors - killed by the Hunter on Night 4 (Villager)
GWB - killed on Night 4 (Hunter)
Lathum - Lynched Day 5 (Werewolf)

Survivors:

Airhog - Duke
Barkeep49
KevinNU7
Mustang
Desnudo
Eaglesfan
Kwhit


Get your night actions in ASAP and we'll turn this back around for another day.

Oh shit.

I knew it. Sorry deacon, I should have stuck to my guns.

Well that sucked. IMO he should have gone earlier do to his lack of posting. Well if I live I'm voting for KWhit

I'll flip flop too if they come in late. I'm sure a few people would to make sure it isn't a tie but, Barkeep is a known villager detected by the seer, isn't he? I'm trying to figure out why.. unless the seer sees a cursed as a regular villager? That or, it sure wasn't Jon that was the target the other night and they happened upon the cursed.. guess it explains the desire to want to get a new player in there.. although, new player.. unfamiliar I guess...

So much for a Friday end...


(In other news, my workday SUCKS so far... I hate month ends...)

IMO I think Airhog is gone "tonight" There isn't many people left and the wolf/wolves will want to eliminate anyone who is obviously not a wolf

Would Airhog have lived so long if he hadn't revealed himself as the Duke so early? Discuss. :)

There were a lot better reasons to vote for others, meaning KWhit and Lathum, than Deacon. Number one being that Airhog was voting for Deacon.

Well that sucks. We're out a villager, and now everybody's MORE convinced I'm a wolf.


:(

Crap.. Didn't see the results while I was typing up... :(

So, what is going to happen now with the weekend? continuing on or??

Mine is typically the Mon, Tuesday and Wednesday until 1pm after the month ends. Our company has given us the 4th AND 5th off. Guess when the month closes for us? You guessed it, still Wednesday at 1pm. Fun

It seems likely we'll be playing through the weekend at this point. If everyone could post their availability for the Sat-Sun-Monday period it would help me decide how to set the timeline.

Well it looks to me like BarKeep isn't a wolf. He came in and tied the votes when you could have put Deacon, a non-wolf away.

Looks like there's atleast 2 wolfs left!

Peregrine, I am without internet until Tuesday afternoon, starting tomorrow morning :( I can be replaced if need be

Nobody's getting replaced at this point, we'll just sit tight through the weekend if we have to. I'm heading out to lunch now and will be gone for a couple of hours, we should definitely have time for one more day/night cycle today, more if people are available later on tonight.

A tie helps the wolves.. they would have gotten a free kill tonight.

Or there's only one left and it isn't me (who it seems obvious that everyone wants to lynch).

With his ability to pick out and vote for innocent villagers, I don't think the wolfs would have eaten him.

I don't understand your reasoning here. Barkeep voted to make a tie. A tie helps the wolves.

To me it looks like Barkeep is a wolf himself and knew that me and Deacon are just villagers. It was obvious that Deacon and I were the next two to be lynched, so he decided to try to get a tie and a free wolf kill.

Or am I missing something obvious?

:confused:

guess thats what I get for sleeping in this morning....

hmm, you raise a good point. If you were just a villager that would be a good stragedy

Remember the seer told us he know of 2 people who were human other than myself.

1. Eaglesfan27
2. Neuqua
3. Airhog

Those 3 people obviously can be eaten tonight. Im not trying to make a case for not eating me. But remember we still have at least 1 special role,the bodyguard. There is only 4 people then that could be wolves.

1. Denudo - Has had a history of voting for the wolves. The only vote he made that didnt result in an evil role was qwikshot in round 4

2. KevinNu7 - I have always figured that he wouldnt get to play the werewolf twice in a row. His voting pattern seems to suggest that.

3. Kwhit - He flew under the radar up until the whole Jon debacle. He did vote for swaggs. But if I knew one of my wolf buddies was gonna be eatin, I might vote him off to. I need to check when he voted, if it was late or early though, that could be a decided factor on if I vote him next time.

4. Mustang - He has only actually voted to get rid of lathum and swaggs. All of his other votes were for people that were lynched that round. If he is the wolf, he has played a most brillant game.

So it looks to me like there is 1, maybe 2 more wolves. If that is the case we will be down to 6 villagers after this night. and 4 after the next night. I think we have some breathing room, unless there are 3 wolves still.

Yes, the seer viewed barkeep way back when I called him out in round 2. He stated he wasn't a wolf, and I have no reason to believe that the Seer would lie. Do wolves have such short memories?

No.. I'm not suggesting Airhog is this .. but, could you imagine if next game you started combining roles like a Cursed Duke or a Hunter Seer? THAT would be a paranoid game....

So why did I tie it up? Because I thought it more likely that KWhitt was a wolf than ntn. That proved to be right. I had hoped that one of the ntn voters would have switched their vote. I think if we hadn't been rushing to try and finish before the weekend that could have happened.

Besides the fact that the seer saw my previous incarnation, a tie helps the wolves less than having an innocent villager killed if there is a no kill.

Hopefully the game does not end tonight.

An additional possibility, however remote, is that one of the viewed, was actually cursed and attacked, not Jon.

However, the person with a big blinking sign over his head that says I'm a werewolf is KWhit. Look beyond the vote to the initial accusation posts. He comes to Lathum's defense and accuses NTNDeacon. He had also tried to bring up deacon's name in a previous post, prior to Jon's accusation of Lathum. Since deacon is now known as a villager, that puts additional condemnation on him. I stupidly switched my vote for deacon, when I knew that KWhit is a werewolf.

Should I be eaten tonight, I would hope that everyone will see the obvious the next time around.

Well, lets get this ball rolling, even if none of us has been eatin yet.

I vote Kwhit

I guess if I die tonight this vote doesnt count :D

This shows the votes of everyone still alive, and not a wolf. Remember, if someone is the cursed, they wont know it, and they wont know who the wolves are. So, in the event that one of the villagers is cursed, their voting pattern not helpful.


Red = Wolf
Yellow = Those who knew who the wolfs were

Player

Round 1

Round 1

Round 1 F.

Round 2

Round 3

Round 3 F.

Round 4

Round 4 F.

Round 5 F.

Round 6

Round 6 F.

Round 7

Desnudo

Desnudo

Airhog

Airhog

Airhog

Condors

Condors

brianD

lathum

Swaggs

Kwhit

KevinNU7

KevinNU7

Airhog

Airhog

Airhog

Qwikshot

Qwikshot

KWHIT

Swaggs

ntndeacon

Kwhit

Kwhit

Nomyths

Nomyths

Airhog

BrianD

jon

swaggs

ntndeacon

Lathum

Lathum

Airhog

Airhog

Airhog

Qwikshot

Qwikshot

eaglesfan27

eaglesfan27

jon

DEAD

DEAD

DEAD

Mustang

Mustang

Airhog

Nomyths

Airhog

Condors

Condors

ntndeacon

ntndeacon

lathum

swaggs

ntndeacon

Swaggs

Swaggs

Airhog

Qwikshot

Qwikshot

Desnudo

jon

ntndeacon

Kwhit

DEAD

Qwikshot

Qwikshot

Shorty

Shorty

Neuqua

Eaglesfan27

Eaglesfan27

DEAD

DEAD

DEAD

DEAD

DEAD

DEAD

There have been 3 no-kill nights if you count the first night. Jon says that he viewed Nequa on the second night. He could be the cursed and now a werewolf.

The tie vote was very strange to me. Especially when he said at the time that:


Is "slightly more reason" enough to risk a tie? I wouldn't have risked the tie unless I was really sure, which he obviously wasn't. Unless he's the wolf.

Most of you sleep uneasily tonight, not sure what will happen next after the lynching of yet another villager. The day dawns at well below freezing and it doesn't look like it will get much warmer, snow is piling up outside the manor. You gather in the main room, count heads, then count your blessings. No one was killed last night.

Day 8

Jon - killed on Night 7 (seer)
Swaggs - Lynched on Day 6 (werewolf)
TazFTW - Lynched on Day 2 (villager)
NoMyths - killed on Night 5 (Sorceror)
Qwikshot - Lynched on Day 3 (Cultist)
ntndeacon - lynched on Day 7 (Villager)
McSweeny - killed on Night 3 (Witness)
Shorty - Lynched on Day 1 (villager)
BrianD - lynched on Day 4 (Doctor)
Condors - killed by the Hunter on Night 4 (Villager)
GWB - killed on Night 4 (Hunter)
Lathum - Lynched Day 5 (Werewolf)

Survivors:

Airhog - Duke
Barkeep49
KevinNU7
Mustang
Desnudo
Eaglesfan
Kwhit


Let's get those votes in as quickly as we can.

I will say this again though

I vote Khwit

Just wanted to say that I don't feel so bad about my death now. I had been pushing for, and nearly got, a lynching for ntndeacon. It didn't really matter which of us died since both options were bad.

Hmmm...seems to be some strong evidence that Kwhit is an innocent villager. :p

Yes I know my track record has been pretty bad here. But I dont think anyone elses has been much better :D

See that's the thing that sucks. I'm getting lynched because I've been wrong with some votes. But we've all had the same problem.

You guys are wrong again.

:(

Looks like the party is winding down...

Vote KWhit

Well when there is only 4 people to choose from, you dont have much choice....