![]() |
|
Quote:
The difference is at least that Christianity has evolved beyond being savages... and only has the 10 commandments and the golden rule (none of which condone what you speak of). If people would live by my rules on this everything would be so much better. You believe what you want, I believe what I want and I only give a damn about your beliefs if you start thinking that others need to suffer and die because they don't follow your beliefs. Once you cross that line, then we have a problem. |
Quote:
What Flasch says in post 11005 (2 below). It's a lot more complicated than "Islam bad." And this coming from someone who tends to agree with Huntington's "Clash of Civilizations" hypothesis. But that still doesn't mean that all branches of Islam, or all Muslims are our enemies. To perpetrate that worldview, and act in that way, will only be detrimental to us in the end. In the end, we're going to have to work with some branches of Islam - not like we can wipe out all of the Muslims in the world. But you know...I know that's far too "shades of gray" for your "black and white," "absolutes are the only true facts" worldview. It might force you to actually stop and think and make differentiations based upon subtle differences. Fuck that...much easier to just say "everyone who's not a carbon copy of me as far as religion/ethnicity/political ideology/beliefs is a POS." You're intellectually lazy. |
Quote:
I'm amazed you were able to write this sentence given your obvious ability to access porn. Pervert. |
Quote:
"It has been estimated that during the Bosnian War between 20,000 and 50,000 women, mainly Muslim, were raped.[20][21] A Commission of Experts appointed in October 1992 by the United Nations concluded that "Rape has been reported to have been committed by all sides to the conflict. However, the largest number of reported victims have been Bosnian Muslims, and the largest number of alleged perpetrators have been Bosnian Serbs." (from wiki "Yugoslav wars") I guess it was after this all Christians evolved. Catholics must not count or FLDS or abortion doctor killers or... |
Quote:
The 10 commandments are in the Qu'ran as well, although slightly different (but the same principles). The religions are eerily similar. I agree that we keep our crazy religious people under wraps much more than they do. Just saying it's not an issue of Islam vs Christianity, it's an issue of religion in general. Quote:
|
Quote:
OH HE WENT THERE... ![]() ...AGAIN! |
Quote:
Sure, but there's actually Islamic law countries that, as a government, practice the "beating wives is cool" version of Islam. That's a little different than finding weird shit in the front of the bible. |
Quote:
Wow, Islam MUST be the one true religion!! (Weird to see the usual elements who are paranoid about anything Christian now waving the flag of Islam) I mean, isn't it weird to have the president and a mayor so outspoken about how important it is to have a particular religious building in a certain place? Why is this a government issue at all? Whoever owns the land can put what the hell they want there (assuming compliance with reasonable zoning laws), and whatever private citizens don't like it can oppose it or put barriers in the way utilizing legal means (the actual land ownership/usage situation might be more complicated than that, I haven't bothered to look that up). Personally, I'd rather not there be a mosque/prayer area there, but I wouldn't lift a finger to stop it. Part of religious freedom is having religious preferences - even if you're not a practicing member of any religion. One can think that Islam is "worse" than Christianity or Judaism, either because of the philosophies, the practice, the impact in the current world, whatever (Just like one can think that they all suck). |
Quote:
I can understand the mayor getting involved because he is basically making your point; it's private property, do what you want. Obama on the other hand, total mistake. |
Quote:
Yeah - the mayor and the local authorities can say what they want. I agree that it was a mistake for Obama to go and get himself involved. He doesn't really have a say in it, and because the right-wing media was up in arms about it and trying to rally support against it and essentially calling him out for allowing it, he decided that he should make it his business, when he really should have just made a statement saying "it's a local issue...i have no influence in it" and left it at that. instead, he tried to do too much (yet again), and let somebody else dictate the battlefield. weak. |
Quote:
You're morally bankrupt. I'll take my chances with my flaws, wouldn't want to live a second with yours. |
Quote:
:lol: See - the funny thing is that I'm only morally bankrupt in your eyes because you have an intellectually lazy uncompromising worldview. I think it's safe to say that the vast majority of posters on this board would say that I do indeed have morals. Hell, even most of those who don't agree with my morals would agree that at least I have morals. They might disagree with what they are, but they would agree that I have them. |
Quote:
He basically said, "it's a local issue and we have freedom of religion, so get over it." Bloomberg and Obama only spoke out because it became the mainstream opinion of the GOP that the government should stop Muslims from building houses of worship. If the outrage wasn't so pronounced and high profile there wouldn't have been a response. Personally I admire both men for standing up and defending one of our core founding principles. |
I love this.
Quote:
|
|
Regardless of their knowledge of Islam, when they repeatedly talk about a mosque at ground zero they're obviously full of shit.
|
Quote:
You could have a bank account too, but if there's nothing of value in it ... |
Quote:
Yep, they're real statesmen. Just following in the proud tradition of FDR & Truman when they supported German & Japanese efforts to build recruiting centers all over the country back in the 40's. Oh wait. |
Quote:
Because you say so? Get over yourself... :rolleyes: |
Quote:
That is such a laughable statement. You lose ALL credibility as soon as you say that. There is no reason to even listen to you at that point. |
Quote:
It's not a mosque and it's not at ground zero. Saying something is what it is not is generally referred to as lying. |
Quote:
Look around. In TN, in CA, in NY there are largely GOP groups opposing the construction of mosques. A leading figure of the Christian right said that no new mosques should be built in the US. I'm honestly surprised that you don't agree with what I stated. Opposing mosques isn't a fringe position within the GOP. |
Quote:
You must be new to this board, people stopped listening to each other years ago. |
Quote:
It's not a mosque??? According to wikipedia it is. Quote:
I think the coup de grace for the Islamic extremists is when they can have the call to prayer broadcast to earshot of ground zero every day. The terrorists are undoubtedly going to very much appreciate our efforts to honor their dead comrades. I doubt we can stop it, but I don't have to sit here and talk about how wonderful of an idea it is because it's not. |
After reading what Obama actually said, I don't know what else he could have said (except nothing)
"I was not commenting and I will not comment on the wisdom of making a decision to put a mosque there. I was commenting very specifically on the right that people have that dates back to our founding." There ya go, I don't think you can disagree with that. What avenue to people "opposed" to the mosque think the government should take, exactly? Make Islam illegal? |
Quote:
I'm sure that's the position of some, for sure. |
Quote:
![]() Oh wait. |
To those of you who appear to be equating Islam with Terrorism.
I lived in England and commuted through London when the IRA were conducting their bombing campaigns. On frequent occasions trains and busses I was travelling on were delayed because of suspect devices (including a few bomb squad detonations). Strangely though just because a subversive Christian group were terrorising the country we didn't prevent anyone from building Christian churches .... terrorists might hide partially behind a religion but its power and influence they're interested in, don't tar all believers of whatever relgion it is just because of a few idiots. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
When they start blarring their "Call to Prayers" out across the WTC memorial everyday, they will be doing a much better job of equating Islam to 911 than folks on this message board could ever do. I would say that the damage they will do to the image of their religion is a valid argument for not building it. |
Quote:
Huh? Why would a community center with an auxiliary prayer area inside blare out a "call to prayer?" |
Quote:
If that's all he said then that's fine. But I still maintain that a large part of his problem is that he's been too reactive and not proactive enough with things like this - letting the GOP and the right-wing media define the battlefields. |
Quote:
In general I agree, but in his instance the only reason anything had to be said was because of the right wing freak show. If Newt, Palin et al didn't try to make this an issue there would be no need for Bloomberg or Obama to defend the 1st amendment. |
Quote:
Most mosques are "inside". |
Quote:
This isn't a mosque per se. Expecting external blaring calls to prayer from a Islamic community center of this nature is like expecting a Christian community center with a small chapel inside to ring loud bells outside as if it did large regular masses. |
Quote:
From what I've read, the Islamic Center will house a mosque capable of offering prayer 5 times daily AND provide for 2,000 to have Friday sermon and teachings. It's not comparable to a small chapel. Now, whether or not they have a loudspeaker "call to prayer" is debatable, I don't know, I'm going off past visual/audible experiences of how mosques generally work. |
Quote:
Ahh, so getting worked up over an assumption you don't know to be true. |
Quote:
Never heard of a mosque in the US that broadcast loudspeaker "call to prayer." I know it's common elsewhere, but I've never even heard of it happening here in the US. And insofar as this is a moderate sect and a moderate leader who has in the past shown an inclination to be respectful I'd presume that they wouldn't either. Plus...there's noise ordinances to consider also. Maybe that's why you don't get that here in the US. |
Quote:
Based on traditional Islam, it's not an assumption. DT better clarifies it for me though. |
I guess we were working from opposite assumptions. I never remembered any loud calls to prayer coming from mosques in Minneapolis.
|
Quote:
There's already 100 full-blown "mosques" in New York City - I'm not sure that they don't practice calls to prayer, but I'd be pretty surprised if they did and this wasn't a huge news story already. It's not like there's little rural areas in NYC you can tuck these places away in. I don't seem to remember the right being all up in arms over these "recruiting centers" in NYC during the Bush administration. One of the amazing things about NYC, and "ground zero", is that it's not like going to the Vietnam Memorial in D.C or something - city life goes on, as it has for years. You'd have to pay attention to even know you were near the site of the attacks. Sure, there's a risk that this place becomes something more than a "mosque" (really just because of the attention everyone's paying to it). I hope that we monitor the shit out of it. |
Quote:
I'm basing my info on mosques in the Middle East. If Stateside mosques don't have a call to prayer 5 times daily and this mosque isn't disruptive to the 9/11 site, I'm less inclined to think it's a big deal. |
There goes that damn constitution getting in the way of discrimination again...
|
Quote:
Absolutely. Within legal means, of course. |
Quote:
Do we know if women will be allowed in there? Islamic men are allowed to get almost naked with each other. Most of the stricter rules only apply to women, in practice. |
Quote:
Are you a closet muslim or something? I must admit its refreshing to see you so passionately defending the practice of a religion. I guess anything the right opposes you need to become a strong supporter of. I mean, we freak out on this board over "christian-influenced" law preventing gay marriage. Under "islamic-influenced" laws, those gays can be executed. Presumably, no gays will be executed at this particular "prayer center", but I'm sure many member/attendees make religious pilgrimages to a place where they are (in fact, they're required to, if they're good muslims) Shouldn't Islam get at least as much venom from the far left as Christianity? |
Are there smaller sects of Islam, like Christianity, that don't oppose homosexuality, equal rights for women, etc?
Protestan christianity is a very different animal than the than the christianity that the right makes so visible. Perhaps the same is true in Islam, and I'm being unfair making the generalizations. But I grew up Lutheran, a church that has openely gay members (and now, openly gay pastors). I did the whole confirmation/sunday school thing and nobody ever taught me anything about gays or abortion being bad. It was mostly just hippie jesus, which I think is actually a great, hugely tolerant philosophy, regardless of what anyone believes about the "literal truth" of the religion (something at least the Lutherans I grew up with didn't care about in the least). Islam IS different, as far as I know. If you're a Muslim, Mecca and Medina aren't optional. It's not like the pope RE: Christianity. If you're a Muslim, you don't get to opt out of the Middle East version, or at least, there certainly hasn't been any wide-spread attempts at a mainstream, more tolerant sect of Islam, compatable with Western laws and ideas. That does make Islam more dangerous. |
Quote:
I'm not an Islamic expert, so I'll refrain from commenting on different strains there. However, you're not really correct on protestantism. There certainly are tolerant churches like you grew up in, but some of the more conservative forms of Christianity are in protestant churches (ie Southern Baptist, Seven Day Adventist, etc.) I also think it's important to remember that Christianity had a six hundred year head start on Islam. It doesn't excuse a lot of the really awful laws and customs in most Islamic countries, but it looks different if you compare it to Christianity in the 1400s. |
Quote:
Completely off the subject, but the only time I've ever questioned my non-Christian, agnostic lifestyle has been in a Lutheran Church. Wasn't enough to get me to convert, but if I ever decided one day to start going to church I'd head straight to my local Lutheran church. |
Quote:
Should that day arrive, just make sure you go ELCA and not Missouri Synod. :) The latter is NOT what you have in mind.... (Also, Lutheran chicks are hot). |
Quote:
It was definitely an ELCA church. Won't argue on the women either. The best looking church-going women in our town are definitely at that church. |
Quote:
Sounds like a different kind of Sunday worship. ;) |
Quote:
Not to mention the attractive female pastor they have too. |
But do they put out like the catholic girls?
|
Quote:
That is they're fairly chilled, they don't take it 'too seriously' and aren't about to go nuclear over their beliefs in a hurry. My dentist back in England was a Moslem and he had Christian staff, they ribbed each other about the differences in holidays and fasts etc. in the same way which people back home do about supporting different soccer teams - nothing nasty; just good natured wind ups. (to be honest Christians in America seem more 'devout/hardcore' than Moslems back home ...) |
Quote:
Uh-oh. Now you've done it Marc. Queue the 'not true christians' rallying cry. |
Another really important issue for the FL governor:
|
I think that all the GOP candidates getting raging boners over Islamic Center outrage might be the least bad option for the Democrats. What's the other conversation option here? 10% unemployment? An unsustainable deficit? As the incumbent party, the Democrats don't really have answers for those.
But, if the GOP keeps this Islamic Center pressure up, I could see an eventual Dem pivot to "The only answer the GOP has to your unemployment is a noun, a verb, and an Islamic Center on the other side of the country." I'm not saying that this is a winning hand for the Dems. But maybe its like holding a pair of threes when you thought that you were holding nothing. |
Except that now the Senate majority leader has come out against the mosque as well.
Regardless, how any of this is important for a FL governor is beyond me. I'd actually want to hear about how you are going to benefit FL rather than how you feel about issues that don't impact FL. |
Those damned Republicans and their focus on issues that don't matt ... umm, never mind.
My Way News - Reid against plan to build mosque near ground zero WASHINGTON (AP) - The Senate's top Democrat on Monday came out against plans to build a mosque near the site of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, moving away from President Barack Obama on the controversial election-year issue. Locked in a tight race, Nevada Sen. Harry Reid became the highest profile Democrat to respond to Obama, who last week backed the right for the developers to build a mosque near ground zero. Since his comments Friday, the Democratic president and his aides have worked to explain the statement, which drew criticism from Republicans and Democrats alike. "The First Amendment protects freedom of religion," said Jim Manley, a Reid spokesman. "Senator Reid respects that, but thinks that the mosque should be built some place else." |
Yeah. Reid deserves to lose basically based just on that. Politically insane.
|
A devout Mormon should know better.
Shameful. |
Quote:
It's apparently keeping Rahm busy to prevent a number of other D's from doing the same thing, Reid might just be the start of something. When you've got 2/3rds of the country opposing it -- regardless of your stance on the subject -- it's pretty obvious that it was a bad political step for Obama to take. He's going to find more candidates going the Roy Barnes route & staying as far away from him as possible as November approaches. |
It's a problem short term, but long term it's a bigger issue for the GOP. Already this year they've done their best to lose the Latino and Muslim vote for the next fifty years. They'll likely benefit in 2010 and 2012, but it's a very shortsighted strategy.
|
Sometimes you just have to wait for the dinosaurs to die out.
|
Quote:
He still doesn't say how exactly he would accomplish this. You can't just be "against" something but propose no means to make it go away. |
Quote:
Does he spend a lot of time hanging out at Muslim "community centers"? Because that's the "kind of muslim" at issue here. And I'm not sure Europe is the shining beacon of how Muslims and non-Muslims can get along. |
http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.co...g-nothing.html
Quote:
|
We've had some dumb political issues over the years, but this may rank up there as one of the dumbest fucking things ever.
|
Sorry albion, but I don't believe Sullivan has much credibility left with most conservative voters. Here he seems to rather obviously overlook the reality that the "culture war" is the one most important to win.
|
Quote:
That's true, I found in Civ4 the best thing to do is amass so much culture you assimilate all cities in your radius. |
I wasn't posting it for the credibility of the author but on its own merits. For you, the culture war is the important war, so that post doesn't really speak to you. In fact, you may have the opposite take--an undue focus on economic issues distracts from that about which you most strongly care.
But, for those conservatives most strongly motivated by the desire to reduce deficits and control spending, questioning the utility of cultural wedge issues seems to be a relevant exercise. |
Quote:
Just wanted to make sure this post wasn't lost in the muck. Well done. |
I can't wait for Civ 5 by the way.
|
Quote:
I always found the best way to win was to nuke every big city on the map so you could easily win a diplomatic victory. |
Quote:
Just to clarify, that isn't Sullivan, but a guest blogger, Conor Friedersdorf. |
Quote:
My bad I guess, I just went with the version posted here & took a leap on the author because of the linkage. edit to add: In that context, it's really not surprising. This dumbass has already gushed his support of the location previously, so naturally he'd attack those who understand it for what it is |
Mosque smosque. I'll go so far to say that it may be insensitive to the community, but that will largely be determined after the fact, and by the manner those that visit conduct themselves.
Bottom line though, the government should make no opposition to the building of this mosque or any other. That isn't how this country works. This reminds me of the Arab Emirates company that was acquiring the company that manages some/most functions of port security for the US, and the outcry at that time. IIRC an outcry led by Democrats. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It was still moronic. Considering the UAE is supposedly one of our close allies. |
Quote:
Pretty much "They are Arabs, and can't be trusted with our security". There were no substantive elements to the objection. Only baseless hypothetical scenarios and conjecture. I believe the thread on that topic here is the one that got me suspended ever so briefly. My assessment at that time, is that the issue then was simple racism and intolerance as well as an appeal to the base characteristics of society, much as this issue is now. |
Can we please evolve and get rid of mass religion? I still think the whole mosque thing was done for publicity.
|
Quote:
+1 Marx was right about religion. |
I'm really pissed that the Burlington Coat Factory is going out of business.
|
Quote:
That is the real travesty in all of this that is being overlooked. |
this is like fucking hilarious. follow @dameshek on twitter...dude is awesome |
If you overuse lens flare the terrorists win.
|
JJ Abrams is a terrorist?
|
Quote:
Say it Ain't So! Edit: Oh Only that one Store! Man I went hard after that one. Still I fear they will go the way of Circuit City. |
Sounds like you'd like the Rude Pundit to nail you!
|
1 Attachment(s)
.
|
Not all of the conservatives have gone batshit crazy. |
Ted Olson is just a RINO.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Wow, I'm surprised that not everyone has been hearing about these issues. I googled "mosque noise issue" and the top was a link to a complaint about a mosque with a "loud call to prayer" in the Bronx. Granted the site's name itself doesn't lend it any credibility as an independent source, but I've been hearing about communities all over the country complaining about "Noisy" calls to prayer for the past few years. I didn't watch the video in the link above, but I've heard examples of what neighborhoods are subjected to on NPR, and it would be quite annoying. I think it is largely based on the Imam, and his willingness to be a good neighbor or unwillingness to compromise his beliefs in any way. That is my uneducated and uninformed opinion about the motivation, but there are clearly several communities struggling with this issue. |
Good Lord. Just when this couldn't get any dumber, Pelosi chimes in........
AUDIO - Rep. Pelosi calls for investigation of WTC mosque opposition - Washington Times This whole issue is just obnoxious. |
...eh, left out a bit of equalizing there to fit the narrative.
typical. Quote:
|
More proof that muslims are violent.
Quote:
My Senator has been pied down in his prime by this terrorist. |
Quote:
There's nothing equalizing about it. It's idiotic that any leader, not to mention the person 3rd in line to be president is wasting any time with this stupidity. There's obviously a side bet between Democrats and Republicans to see who can make the dumber statements this week. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:53 PM. |
|
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.6.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.